2007 Decisions

 
 
* Chairpersons:


A.Deg. - Anthony Degiovanni
A.C. – Alphonse Caruana
C.D. - Carmel Debono
F.M. - Franco Masini
G.B.C. - George Borg Cardona
H.W. -  Harold Walls
J.B. - Dr. Joseph P. Bonnici LLD
L.C. - Dr. Leslie Cuschieri LLD
M.F. - Dr. Martin Fenech LLD


Decision  Number 
& Type

 ​Date

Parties

 Subject

Chairperson* 

 1750
Final

 05/01/2007

 Patrick Briffa
vs
Nylon Knitting Company Limited

 Unfair Dismissal

 

A.Deg.

 

1751
Final

 08/01/2007

Universita Ta' Malta
vs
UMASA, MUT​
 

 Union Recognition

A.C.

1752
Final

 10/01/2007

 John Bartolo
vs
Vella Falzon Building Supplies Ltd​

 Unfair Dismissal

F.M. 

 1753
Final

 12/01/2007

Lorraine Williams
vs
Maltacom Plc & Telepage Ltd.​

Alleged Change in Work Conditions

 J.B.

 1754
Final

 26/01/2007

 Anna Marie Navarro
vs
Aeolos Malta Limited

Unfair Dismissal 

 H.W.

1755
Final

31/01/2007

Marco Ciantar
vs
Sovereign Hotels Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal 

H.W.

1756
Final

12/02/2007

Ramonn Zerafa
vs
Kemimport Limited​

 

Unfair Dismissal 

 

M.F.

1757
Final

14/02/2007

David Mallia
vs
Winston’s Medina Restaurant Ltd​

Unfair Dismissal 

F.M. 

1758
Final

19/02/2007

Marina Galea Xuereb
vs
Enemalta Corporation

 

Unfair Dismissal 

 

M.F.

1759
Final

26/02/2007

Damian Iwueke
vs
Foundation for International Studies​

Unfair Dismissal

A.C.

1760
Final

28/02/2007

John Scicluna
vs
Best Western Les Lapins​

Unfair Dismissal

 

C.D.

 1761
Final

 05/03/2007

 Francesco Toledo
vs
Vittoriosa Gaming Limited​

 

Unfair Dismissal

 

 G.B.C.

 1762
Final

07/03/2007

Gaetano Tanti
vs
Qawra Palace Hotel​

Unfair Dismissal 

F.M.

 1763
Final

 09/03/2007

Joseph Cutajar
vs
Actavis Ltd
 

Unfair Dismissal 

 F.M.

 1764
Final

 12/03/2007

Simon Borg
vs
Lufthansa Technik Malta Limited​

 Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C. 

 1765
Final

21/03/2007 

 Kevin Nappa
vs
Elmein Ltd​

Unfair Dismissal 

 F.M.

 1766
Final

26/03/2007 

Eguenio Portelli
vs
R.J.C.Caterers Limited​

Unfair Dismissal 

M.F. 

1767
Final

09/04/2007

Darren Fiteni
vs
R.J.C. Caterers Limited

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

1768
Final

09/04/2007

Lawrence Zerafa
vs
R.J.C. Caterers Limited​

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

1769
Final

09/04/2007

Vincent Said
vs
R.J.C. Caterers Limited

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

1770
Final

09/04/2007

Kevin Bezzina
vs
R.J.C. Caterers Limited

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

1771
Final

27/03/2007

Edmund Briffa
vs
Bonu Garage Limited

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1772
Final

28/03/2007

Joseph Vassallo
vs
Joseph Lia​

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

1773
Final

02/04/2007

Joseph sive Josef Perrone
vs
S & R (Handaq) Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

1774
Final

02/04/2007

Paul Grimsey 
vs
Eden Leisure Group Ltd​

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

1775
Final

02/04/2007

Pierre Duca
vs
De La Rue Currency & Security
Print Ltd 

 

Unfair Dismissal

 

F.M.

1776
Final

03/04/2007

Paul Portelli
vs
Enemalta Corporation

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1777
Final

12/04/2007

Diane Hili
vs
Mall Systems Limited​

Unfair Dismissal

 

C.D.

1778
Final

17/04/2007

Angelo Schembri
vs
FontanellaTea Gardens​

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1779
Final

19/04/2007

Joseph Muscat
vs
STMicroelectronics (Malta) Ltd​

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1780
Final

26/04/2007

Paul Camilleri
vs
Kumpanija Frozen Art Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

1781
Final

03/05/2007

Renato Squizzato
vs
Vittoriosa Gaming Limited

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1782
Final

03/05/2007

Simon Pavan
vs
Vittoriosa Gaming Limited​

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1783
Final

07/05/2007

Colin Zammit 
vs
Homemate Company Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1784
Final

07/05/2007

Jesmond Garrett
vs
B & S Manufacturing Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.C.

 1785
Final

 10/05/2007

 GWU
vs
BOV​

Application for Benefits of Consolidated Staff,Widows,Orphans

H.W.

1786
Preliminary

20/05/2007

General Workers’ Union
vs
Dragonara Casino Ltd​

Disciplinary Action 

A.C.

1787
Final 

21/05/2007 

MUBE
vs
BOV

Union Recognition

G.B.C. 

 1788
Final

15/06/2007

Jesmond Nappa Licari
vs
Malta Freeport Terminal Ltd

 Unfair Dismissal

C.D. 

 1789
Final

 20/06/2007

Anthony Azzopardi
vs
Foster Clark Products Limited​

 Unfair Dismissal

F.M. 

 1790
Final

 26/06/2007

Josephine Camilleri
vs
STMicroelectronics (Malta)
Ltd​

 

Unfair Dismissal

 

L.C. 

 1791
Final

 03/07/2007

Anne Bharwani
vs
MIM Training & Development Services Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C. 

 1792
Final

13/07/2007 

Grezzju Azzopardi
vs
PBS Ltd.

Change in Conditions of Employment

 

 J.B.

 1793
Final

 13/07/2007

Jonathan Ferris
vs
GMC Freight Services Limited​
 

 

Unfair Dismissal

 

 J.B.

 1794
Final

13/07/2007 

Irene Bugeja
vs
Vassallo Builders Group Ltd.

 

Unfair Dismissal

 

 J.B.

 1796
Final

20/07/2007

Jason Muscat
vs
St Edward's College

Unfair Dismissal

 

F.M. 

 1797
Final

24/07/2007 

 Vince Galdes
vs
Alphonse Farrugia and Sons Limited


Unfair Dismissal

 

 H.W.

 1798
Final

26/07/2007 

 Godwin Vassallo
vs
Vittoriosa Gaming Limited​


Unfair Dismissal

 

 A.Deg.

 1799 
Final

26/07/2007

Aloysia Rahim Debono
vs
Port Cottonera Hotel Dev. Co.Ltd 

 Unfair Dismissal

 A.Deg.

1800
Final

26/07/2007

Grace Vassallo
vs
Port Cottonera Hotel Dev. Co.Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1801
Final

27/07/2007

Carmel Spiteri
vs
Alfur Limited Comercialy known as ‘Magi Arredamenti’

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1802
Final

27/07/2007

Geniev Zerafa
vs
Phone Direct Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

1803
Final

27/06/2007

Geniev Zerafa
vs
Phone Direct Ltd.

​Alleged harassment

J.B.

1804
Final

27/07/2007

Alfred Farrugia
vs
Sea Malta Company Ltd.

Discriminatory Treatment

J.B.

1805
Final

06/09/2007

Carmen Borg
vs 
Ramla Garden Hotel​

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

1807
Final

11/09/2007

Rosainne Galea
vs
Malta International Training Centre​

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

1808
Final

20/09/2007

Maria Norma Abela
vs
Pater Holding Company Limited &
U.C.I.M. Co. Ltd & 
Clentec Cleaning Services Limited​

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1809
Final

 24/09/2007

 Arthur Walker
vs
Foster Clark Products Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

 G.B.C.

1810
Final 

 27/09/2007

 Cleaven Lovegrove
vs
Sisa Malta Limited

 

Unfair Dismissal

 

 H.W.

1812
Final

08/10/2007 

 Mario Azzopardi
vs
Entertainments
Limited​

 

Unfair Dismissal

 

G.B.C. 

 1814
Final

23/10/2007 

Jason Caruana
vs
Louis Galea
 

 Unfair Dismissal

 H.W.

1815
Final

29/10/2007

Darren Busuttil
vs
Trapless Ltd.​

 Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

1816
Final

29/10/2007

Marcelline Cuschieri
vs
Vigilante Secutiry Services Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

1817
Final

29/10/2007

Marcelline Cuschieri
vs
Personal Security Services Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

1818
Final

30/10/2007

Alessandra Theuma
vs
Alfred Mangion u Anthony Saliba

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

1821
Final

09/11/2007

GWU
vs
RJC Caterers Ltd & 
Corinthia Palace Hotel Co. Ltd.​

Transfer of Business

F.M.

1824
Final

12/11/2007

Renato J.Costigan
vs
Malta Drydocks
&
Malta Shipyards Ltd.​

Termination of employment

M.F.

1826
Final

20/11/2007

Alfred Buttigieg
vs
Malta Shipyards Ltd.

Discriminatory Treatment

L.C.

1829
Final

03/12/2007

Kenneth Vella
vs
Seabank Catering Co.Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.C.

1830
Final

04/12/2007

Mario Farrugia
vs
ABT Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

1831
Final

05/12/2007

John Sammut
vs
Malta Freeport Terminals Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1832
Final

10/12/2007

John Caruana
vs
Grand Hotel Mercure Selmun Palace

Unfair Dismissal

A.C.

1833
Final

10/12/2007

Kristian Debattista
vs
Water Services Corp.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C. 

1834
Final

11/12/2007

Sarah Jane Gialanze
vs
Estetika Co. Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​
​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​