2009 Decisions




* Chairpersons:

 
A.Deg. - Anthony Degiovanni
A.C. - Alphonse Caruana
F.M. - Franco Masini
G.B.C. - George Borg Cardona
H.W. -  Harold Walls
J.B. - Dr. Joseph P. Bonnici LLD
L.C. - Dr. Leslie Cuschieri LLD
M.F. - Dr. Martin Fenech LLD​


Decision Number 
& ​Type

 Date

​Parties

 Subject​

​Chairperso​n*


 1896
Partial

13/01/2009

Rita Borg
vs
Director of Tourism​

 Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

 1897
Final

 15/01/2009

 GWU 
vs 
Bank of Valletta PLC​

 Wrong app. of circular  re Simond Buhagiar​

 A.Deg.

1898
Final 

 15/01/2009

Alexandra Galea
vs 
M.C.A.S.T.​

 Unfair Dismissal

 A.Deg.

1899
Final 

 15/01/2009

Alfred C. Attard
vs
Tony Sciberras de Giovanni (Shigo Teletwist) et. al.

 Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg. 

 1900
Final

 19/01/2009

 Massimo Feroleto
vs
Palazzo Margherita LTD​

 

 Unfair Dismissal

 G.B.C.

 1901
Final

 27/01/2009

Frankie Borg
vs
Perla LTD

Unfair Dismissal 

 H.W.

1902
Preliminary

28/01/2009

Peter Aguis
vs 
Melita PLC

Unfair Dismissal 

F.M.

1903
Final

27/01/2009

Marvic Formosa
vs
General Soft Drinks LTD

Unfair Dismissal 

M.F.

1904
Final

02/02/2009

William Farrugia
vs
Malta Freeport Terminals LTD​

Unfair Dismissal 

M.F.

1905
Final

03/02/2009

Nadia Aquilina
vs
Alitalia-Linee Aeree Italiane SPA

Infringement of the Rights of Work of Equal Value

L.C.

1906
Final

09/02/2009

Rita Fabri
vs
Zammit & Pace LTD

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

1907
Final

13/02/2009

Anthony Berry
vs
Emmanuel Vella &Sons Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg. 

1908
Final

12/02/2009

Grezzju Zammit
vs
John Farrugia

Unfair Dismissal

 H.W.

1909
Partial

17/02/2009

Neil J. Pavia
vs
Mediterranian Aviation Company LTD

Alleged Discrimination

L.C.

 1910
Final

 18/02/2009

Mark Anthony Farrugia
vs
Maltapost PLC

 

Unfair Dismissal

 

 F.M.

 1911
Final

18/02/2009 

Claudio Tonolla
vs
Mediterranean Bank PLC

Unfair Dismissal 

F.M.

 1912
Final

 18/02/2009

Ian Xuereb
vs
Maltapost PLC

Unfair Dismissal 

 F.M.

 1913
Final

 25/02/2009

Emanuel Zerafa
vs
Jason Galea for Xlendi Management Co. LTD ​

 Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg. 

 1914
Final

26/02/2009

Nadia Aquilina
vs
Alitalia​

Infringement of the Rights of Work of Equal Value​

L.C.

 1915
Final

27/02/2009

Chantalle Terreni
vs
Keene Catering Services Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

 1916
Final

28/02/2009 

 Stephen Muscat
vs
Armstrong Co. LTD​

Unfair Dismissal 

 J.B.

 1918
Final

10/03/2009 

 Sunny Degabriele
vs
Marianne Bonnici (director Support Services LTD)

Unfair Dismissal 

L.C. 

1921
Final

12/03/2009

Anglu Mallia
vs
Vassallo Construction LTD

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1922
Final

12/03/2009

Abdelaziz Dhaidhi
vs
Bortex Clothing

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

1923
Final

13/03/2009

Il-Perit Arkitett David Farrugia
vs
Malta Planning and Design Consultants LTD

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

1924
Final

16/03/2009

Charmaine D'Amato
vs
ST Microelectronics (Malta) Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

1926
Final

24/03/2009

Patrick Micallef
vs
M.Demajo Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1927
Final

24/03/2009

Marlom Grima
vs
Santa Katerina Construction Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C. 

1928
Final

30/03/2009

Fortunanta Farrugia 
et. al.
vs
Vittoriosa Gaming LTD

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

1931
Final

17/04/2009

John Scicluna
vs
Leisure Clothing LTD

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

1932
Final

20/04/2009

Ivan Cilia La Corte
vs
J. Grima & Co. LTD

Unfair Dismissal

A.C.

1933
Final

27/04/2009

Jennifer Ben Saad
vs
Consolidated Biscuit Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

1940
Final

20/05/2009

Anthony Saliba
vs
Yorkie Clothing Industries LTD

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

1941
Final

25/05/2009

Joseph Saliba
vs
Imperial Hotel

Unfair Dismissal

A.C.

1942
Partial

26/05/2009

Pauline Vassallo
vs
The Eden Foundation

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

1944
Final

29/05/2009

GWU
vs
Dragonara Casino LTD

Alleged Breach of Collective Agreement

F.M.

1950
Final

25/06/2009

Charles Sciberras
vs
Steel Structures Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

1951 
Final

25/06/2009

Louis Camilleri
vs
Arrow Express LTD​

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1952 
Final

06/07/2009

Ryan Galea
vs
George Xuereb​

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

Final Decree 2530 

10/07/2009

Svetlana Borg
vs
Fashion Retailers Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

 J.B.

1953 
Final

13/07/2009

Lawrence Silvio
vs
Hire & Transport Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

1954 
Final

13/07/2009

Marlene Cauchi
vs
Maltapost plc​

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

1955 
Final

13/07/2009

Pauline Zerafa
vs
Megaline Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

Final Decree 2572 

17/07/2009

Maria Bezzina
vs
S&D Yachts Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

 J.B.

1956 
Final

20/07/2009

GWU
vs
Malta Stock Exchange​

Application of Clause 14 of Terms & Conditions of Malta Stock Exchange

G.B.C.

1957 
Final

24/07/2009

Daniel Vella
vs
Intertek Lab Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

Final Decree 2555 

24/07/2009

Micheal Lombardi
vs
Swan Laundry

Unfair Dismissal

 J.B.

1958 
Final

28/07/2009

Joseph Vella
vs
Cavendish Hotels

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

1959 
Final

02/09/2009

Rosemarie Stagno-Navarra
vs
San Lawrenz Operators Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

1960
Final

15/09/2009

Paul Borg
vs
APS Bank LTD​

Alleged Discrimination

L.C.

1961
Partial

22/09/2009

Keith Micallef
vs
Michael Attard (Imports) LTD

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

1962 
Final

24/09/2009

Paul Micallef
vs
Trelleborg Sealing Solutions Malta LTD

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

1963 
Partial

06/10/2009

Odette Cassar
vs
First United Insurance Brokers​

Unfair Dismissal

L.C

1964
Final

06/10/2009

M.U.B.E.
vs
APS Bank LTD​

Recognition of a Manager's position

H.W.

1965
Final

06/10/2009

Joseph Vella
vs
Bank of Valletta PLC

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

1966 
Preliminary

07/10/2009

Union Haddiema Maghqudin
vs
Medelec Switchgear

Conditions regulating duties abroad for engineers

F.M.

1967
Final

12/10/2009

Joseph Cuschieri
vs
Dolmen Complex LTD

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

 1968
Partial

 27/10/2009

Mirana Azzopardi
vs
Maltapost PLC
 

Unfair Dismissal 

L.C.

1969
Partial

27/10/2009

Dr.Tonio Azzopardi
vs
MCAST

Alleged breach of artricle 75 of the EIRA

L.C.

1970
Final 

30/10/2009 

Alan Micallef
vs
Valmor Borg Import and Export LTD ​

Unfair Dismissal 

J.B. 

 1971
Final

04/11/2009 

Concetta Abela
vs
ADT 

 Unfair Dismissal

F.M. 

 1972
Final

 04/11/2009

 George Winston Schembri
vs
ADT

 Unfair Dismissal

F.M. 

 1973
Final

 17/11/2009

 Mirjana Kovacevic
vs
Myoka Management LTD

Unfair Dismissal 

L.C. 

 1974
Final

 18/11/2009

Andrew Barbara
vs
P.E. Trading LTD​
 

 Unfair Dismissal

F.M. 

 1975 
Final

18/11/2009 

 Natasha Dimandidis
vs
The Guard and Warden House LTD

Unfair Dismissal 

 F.M.

 1976
Final

 30/11/2009

James Pawley
vs
W&M Zammit Tabona LTD 

 Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C. 

1977
Final 

 11/12/2009

Marvic Briffa & Louis Aquilina
vs
ST Micro Electronics LTD ​

 Alleged Discrimination

J.B. ​

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​
​​​​​​​​​​