2011 Decisions



 

* Chairpersons :


A.Deg. - Anthony Degiovanni
E.T. - Edmund Tabone
F.M. - Franco Masini
G.B.C. - George Borg Cardona
H.W. -  Harold Walls
J.B. - Dr. Joseph P. Bonnici LLD
L.C. - Dr. Leslie Cuschieri LLD
M.F. - Dr. Martin Fenech LLD
 
 

Decision Number & Type

Date

Parties

Subject

Chairperson*

Final Decree
2798

10/01/2011

Rendo Borg 
vs
Malta Freeport Terminals Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

       M.F.

Final Decree
2765

11/01/2011

Nicola Bowen
vs
Transforma Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​J.B.

2042
Final

12/01/2011

Ella Meta Krist
vs
Siegfried Generics (Malta) Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2043
Final

12/01/2011

Anthony Carabott
vs
BIM Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

Final Decree
Ref 1501/10/LC

13/01/2011

Micheal Fenech
vs
MIA plc.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

Final Decree
2739

24/01/2011

Edwin Fenech 
vs
Valhmor Borg/Export Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2044
Final

25/01/2011

Ray Falzon
vs
Security Services Malta Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2045
Final

27/01/2011

Eileen Said
vs
Education Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

Final Decree
2857

27/01/2011

Zarko Krstic
vs
Amino Chemicals Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2046
Final

31/01/2011

Joseph Abela
vs
Imperial Hotel
(Goldvest Co. Ltd.)

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2047
Final

31/01/2011

GWU
vs
Dragonara Casino​

Alleged Breach of Collective Agreement

M.F.

2048
Final

31/01/2011

John Psaila
vs
ST Microelectronics (Malta) Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.​​

Final Decree
2846

31/01/2011

UHM
vs
Foster Clark Products Ltd
.

Disciplinary Action

M.F.

2049
Final

02/02/2011

Peter Aguis
vs
Melita plc.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2050
Final

03/02/2011

Elizabeth Camilleri
vs
P.R.Company Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2051
Final

09/02/2011

Melvin Chetcuti
vs
Bartoli Brothers Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2052
Final

09/02/2011

Anthony Bailey
vs
Maltacom plc.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2053
Preliminary

09/02/2011

Clinch Thomas
vs
AirMalta Plc.

Discriminatory Treatment

J.B.

2054
Final

09/02/2011

Silvana Attard
vs
Water Services C​​orporation

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2055
Final

09/02/2011

Stephen Muscat
vs
Armstrong Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2056
Final

09/02/2011

Doreen Genovese
vs
The Superintendent 
Zammit Clapp Hospital

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

Final Decree
2808

17/02/2011

Daniela Frendo
vs
AM.Mangion Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2057
Final

21/02/2011

Carmel Farrugia
vs
BOV plc

Discriminatory Treatment

M.F.

2058
Partial

21/02/2011

Antione Portelli
vs
Smart City Malta Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2057
Final

01/03/2011

Tonio Farrugia
vs
MCAST

Alleged Breach of Article 15 of EIRA

L.C.

Final Decree
2185

03/03/2011

Mary Cefai
vs
One Productions Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

Final Decree
2803

07/03/2011

Go plc & Mobisle Communications Ltd.
vs
UHM

Union Recognition

M.F.

Final Decree
2869

07/03/2011

Bian Bian Lew-Bartkowski
vs
Wagerlogic Malta Software Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

Final Decree
2793

09/03/2011

Ray Chetcuti
vs
Mediterranean Offshore Bunkering Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

Final Decree
2794

09/03/2011

Charles Zammit
vs
Mediterranean Offshore Bunkering Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

Final Decree
2462

11/03/2011

Carmelo Caruana
vs
MIA plc

Alleged
Discriminatory Treatment

J.B.

2060
Final

14/03/2011

Teddy Cilia
vs
Maltapost plc

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

Final Decree
2806

21/03/2011

Rebecca Seychell
vs
Lidl Malta Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2061
Final

22/03/2011

Edoardo Babato
vs
Vittoriosa Gamming Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2062
Final

23/03/2011

Josephine Micallef Smith
vs
Valentina Communications Ltd​

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

Final Decree
2770

24/03/2011

Louise Farrugia
vs
Clentec Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

Final Decree
2881

28/03/2011

Martin Zammit
vs
Alberta Fire & Security Equipment Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2063
Final

04/04/2011

Eleonora Talarico
vs
Referprom Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

Final Decree
2830

06/04/2011

Louis Mifsud
vs
Dominic Refalo
Patrick Refalo

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2064
Final

08/04/2011

Christine Bonnici
vs
BDO Attard Buttigieg Psaila & Co.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2065
Final

13/04/2011

Norman Mayo
vs
SL Ship Management Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2066
Final

13/04/2011

MEPA 
vs
GWU and Union of Technical and Clericals

Disagreement on employees'
conditions

F.M.

Final Decree
2516

18/04/2011

Airest Malta Ltd.
vs
GWU

Transfer of Employees

L.C.

Decree
2878

20/04/2011

GWU
vs
Enemalta Corporation

Disagreement on Overtime Allocation

A.Deg.

Final Decree
2733

28/04/2011

Edward Mallia
vs
University of Malta​

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2067
Final

06/05/2011

Mario Psaila
vs
Melita plc​

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2068
Final

06/05/2011

Mario Psaila
vs
Melita plc

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2069
Final

06/05/2011

Joseph Mula
vs
Coastline Hotel Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

Decree
2836

09/05/2011

Nicholas Caruana Turner
vs
Malta Freeport Terminals Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2070
Partial

10/05/2011

Diego Righi
vs
Emerald Shipping Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2071
Final

12/05/2011

Dennis Waites
vs
Attrans Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2072
Final

12/05/2011

Mario Sciberras
vs
Medserv Operations Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2073
Final

12/05/2011

UHM
vs
Air Malta plc

Alleged Injustice against Employee

E.T.

2074
Final

09/05/2011

Harry Calleja
vs
Maltapost plc​

Alleged Discriminatory Treatment

M.F.

2075
Final

13/05/2011

Rachel Bugeja
vs
PSG Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2076
Final

18/05/2011

Lucienne Scicluna
vs
M.H.Malta Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2077
Final

27/05/2011

Peter Brincat 
vs
Edrichton Holidays Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

Final Decree
2753

30/05/2011

Charmaine Abela
vs
Raiffeisen Malta Bank plc​

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2078
Final

02/06/2011

Mary Josephine Camilleri
vs
GasanMamo Ins Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2079
Final

02/06/2011

Salvu Zahra
vs
John Farrugia, Alexia Farrugia, Paul Farrugia, Farrugia Lightning & Interiors​

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2080
Final

02/06/2011

Brenda Zammit
vs
Elaine Busuttil

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2081
Final

09/06/2011

Melvic Aguis
vs
Maypole Holdings Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2082
Final

13/06/2011

Maria Vella
vs
Proud Caterers Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

Final Decree
2905

15/06/2011

Laurence Hili
vs
Melita Marine Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2083
Preliminary

16/06/2011

Charlene Vella
vs
Banif Bank (Malta) plc

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2084
Final

21/06/2011

Lino Bugeja
vs
Slipform Engineering International Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2085
Final

21/06/2011

Kevin Aquilina
vs
Uniblu Systems Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

Final Decree
2872

22/06/2011

Godwin Bowerman
vs
Goldvest Company Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2086
Final

27/06/2011

Raymond Camilleri
vs
Meli Car Rentals Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2087
Final

28/06/2011

Aaron Sultana
vs
Calypso MFG Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2088
Final

24/06/2011

Joseph Zarb
vs
JF Security

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2089
Final

01/07/2011

David D'Anastas
vs
Themoplastics Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2090
Final

06/07/2011

Nazzareno Falzon
vs
AirMalta plc

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2091
Final

11/07/2011

Simon  Tonna
vs
American Embassy

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

Final Decree
2850

07/07/2011

Loredana Ragusa
vs
G4S Security Services (Malta) Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2092
Final

12/07/2011

Joseph Genovese
vs
Hotel Bernard Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2095
Final

14/07/2011

Tug Malta Ltd.
vs
Malta Dockers' Union

Ships' Manning Levels

A.Deg.

2093
Final

15/07/2011

Doreen Anastasi
vs
Pinnacle Gaming Group Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2094
Final

18/07/2011

Vanessa mart Keith Harmsworth
vs
Yellow Pages (Malta) Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

Final Decree
2903

18/07/2011

Joseph D'Ugo
vs
Grand Hotel Excelsior Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

Decree
2919

20/07/2011

GWU
vs
Enemalta Corporation

Suspension of employees

A.Deg.

2096
Final

22/07/2011

Anthony DeBono
vs
John's Garage Ltd
.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2097
Final

29/07/2011

Mario Muscat
vs
Windmill Limited

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2098
Final

23/08/2011

Mark Buhagiar
vs
Gozo Express Services Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2099
Final

05/09/2011

Melaine Muscat Foden
vs
Foster Clark Products Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

Final Decree
2930

12/09/2011

Josephine Cachia
vs
Education Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2100
Final

15/09/2011

Anthony Farrugia
vs
Anthony Busuttil

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

Final Decree
2924

23/09/2011

Carmelo Dalli
vs
Go plc

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2101
Final

26/09/2011

Sandra Nikolic
vs
G.C.C.L. HMD Fleet Management Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2102
Final

26/09/2011

Justin Spiteri
vs
Support Services Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

Decree
2905

28/09/2011

Laurence Hili
vs
Melita Maratime Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2103
Final

29/09/2011

Marcelle Vella
vs
Vascas Ent. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

Final Decree
2921

07/10/2011

Janica Schembri
vs
PAVI Supermarkets

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2104
Final

07/10/2011

Rachel Buhagiar
vs
Carmel Caruana Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2105
Final

12/10/2011

Remi Armeni
vs
Francis Busuttil &  Sons Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

Final Decree
2922

14/10/2011

Richard Findley
vs
Betting Promotions Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

Final Decree
2932

18/10/2011

Amanda Dimech
vs
2X Software Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2106
Final

24/10/2011

Sharon Mizzi
vs
Maltapost plc.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2107
Final

27/10/2011

Andrea Cini
vs
Premier Restuarants Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2108
Final

28/10/2011

Godwin Calleja
vs
Medichem Manufacturing Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2109
Final

01/11/2011

Glynis Pace
vs
British High Commision (Malta)

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2110
Final

01/11/2011

Benjamin Bugeja
vs
British High Commission (Malta)

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2111
Final

08/11/2011

Mirana Azzopardi
vs
Maltapost plc

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2112
Final

09/11/2011

Ray Mangion
vs
CHI Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2113
Final

15/11/2011

Slavisa Lapcevic
vs
TGS Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

Final Decree
2943

18/11/2011

Antionette Chircop
vs
Eden Hospitality Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2114
Final

21/11/2011

Paul Said
vs
Emmanuel Delicata Winemakers Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2115
Final

22/11/2011

Vito Benvenga
vs
The Director General Department for Agriculture & Fisheries Regulations

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2116
Final

23/11/2011

Vincent Bezzina
vs
Five Star Hotels Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

Decree
2716

01/12/2011

Anthony Carabott
vs
BIM Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2117
Final

05/12/2011

Godwin Cassar
vs
Bonavia Bros. Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

Final Decree
2913

05/12/2011

Joseph Abela 
vs
Metalfit Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2118
Partial

06/12/2011

Antionette Vella
vs
CareMalta Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.​

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​
​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​