2012 Decisions


​​​

* Chairpersons :

A.Deg. - Anthony Degiovanni
E.T. - Edmund Tabone
F.M. - Franco Masini
G.B.C. - George Borg Cardona
H.W. -  Harold Walls
J.B. - Dr. Joseph P. Bonnici LLD
L.C. - Dr. Leslie Cuschieri LLD
M.F. - Dr. Martin Fenech LLD
M.G. - Mary Gaerty
C.A - Chris Attard
J.H. - Joan Haber
C.C. - Charles Cassar
V.V. - Dr.Vanessa Vella LLD

 

Decision Number & Type

Date

​Parties​

Subject

Chairperson*

2119​
Final

10/01/2012

Lawrence Mangion 
vs
Francis Busuttil & Sons Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

          Final                Decree      2876

16/01/201​2

Oriana Farrugia
vs
Target Media Ltd. et

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2120
Partial

17/01/2012

Carmelo Aguis
vs
Antione Tanti

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

          Final                Decree      2912

18/01/2012

Karen Houston
vs
Overland Trading (Malta) Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2121
Final

18/01/2012

Nicholas Caruana Turner
vs
Malta Freeport

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

          Final               Decree       2985

27/01/2012

Graham Crawford
​vs
​Wagerlogic Malta Software Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2122
Final

13/02/2012

Carmelo Seychell
vs
BIM Ltd.

Re-employment of redundant employee

G.B.C.

2123
Final

14/02/2012

Charles Cutajar
vs
S.Mifsud & Sons Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

          Final                Decree        2839

20/02/2012

Louis Charland
vs
Comlux Services Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2124
Final

20/02/2012

Salvina Saliba
vs
Cassar Weaving Ltd. et

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2125
Final

20/02/2012

Alfred Littlejohn
vs
French Embassy

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2126
Final

21/02/2012

UHM
vs
Lufthansa Technik

Allowance to Trainee Tradesman

H.W.

2127
Final

22/02/2012

Godfrey Zammit
vs
Chef Choice Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2128
Final

17/02/2012

Roderick Borg
vs
Hospitality Services Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2129
Final

23/02/2012

Natalino Xuereb
vs
Emmanuel Delicata & Sons Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2130
Final

05/03/2012

Yvonne Busuttil
vs
J&K Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2131
Final

05/03/2012

Union WSC Professionals
vs
WSC

Position of Senior Engineer

M.F.

2132
Final

14/03/2012

Micheal Wilson
vs
Arrow Pharm Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2133
Final

14/03/2012

Olaf Woods
vs
Vivaldi Hotels Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2134
Final

14/03/2012

Martin Fenech
vs
Vassallo Builders Group Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2135
Preliminary

15/03/2012

Roberta Balzan
vs
Maltapost plc.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2136
Final

20/03/2012

Marvin Abdilla
vs
Engineering for Science & Industry Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2137
Final

20/03/2012

Micheal Azzopardi
vs
Engineering for Science & Industry Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2138
Final

27/03/2012

GWU
vs
Awtorita ghat-Trasport f'Malta

Union Recognition

L.C.

2139
Final

02/04/2012

Robert Aquilina
vs
Camilmac Services Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2140
Preliminary

04/04/2012

Mario Sammut
vs
Joseph Camilleri

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2141
Final

05/04/2012

GWU
vs
Maltapost

Interpretation of Disciplinary Procedure

F.M.

          Final               Decree      2888

13/04/2012

Stephanie Azzopardi
vs
Baker Tilly Sant Auditors & Accountants

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2142
Final

12/04/2012

Carmelo Vella 
vs
Gozo Aluminium Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2143
Final

19/04/2012

John Debono
vs
WasteServ Malta Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

          Final              Decree   
 2763

20/04/2012

Joseph Falzon
vs
The Nuance Group Malta Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2144
Final

20/04/2012

Jesmond Farrugia
vs
Awtorita tad-Djar

Breach of work contract

J.B.

2145
Final

23/04/2012

Mildred Marmara
vs
Dragonara Casino Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2146
Final

07/05/2012

GWU
vs
Central Bank of Malta

Alleged breach of collective agreement

G.B.C.

2147
Final

07/05/2012

Pauline Spiteri
vs
G.Pisani Marketing Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2148
Final

07/05/2012

Frederick Attard
vs
MIA plc.

Alleged Discriminatory Treatment

M.F.

2149
Final

07/05/2012

Frederick Attard
vs
MIA plc.

Alleged Discriminatory Treatment

M.F.

2150
Final

09/05/2012

Tracey Camilleri
vs
John's Garage Ltd. et

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

          Final                Decree        2945

11/05/2012

MTA
vs
GWU

Collective Agreement

J.B.

          Final                Decree        2993

14/05/2012

UHM
vs
Maltco Lotteries​

Union Recognition

C.A.

2151
Final

14/05/2012

Martin Chetcuti
vs
MRCD Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2152
Final

16/05/2012

Kevin Aguis
vs
Caprice Glass Works Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

          Final                Decree       2732

21/05/2012

Marco Schembri
vs
Masco Security Services Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2153
Final

28/05/2012

Charles Vella
vs
GWU

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2154
Final

29/05/2012

Reuben Zammit
vs
Kunsill Lokali Naxxar

Discriminatory Treatment

L.C.

          Final                Decree        2996

31/05/2012

Katrin Micallef Risiott
vs
Link School of Languages

Unfair Dismissal

M.G.

2155
Final

04/06/2012

Publius Davison
vs
De La Rue et

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2156
Final

04/06/2012

Marco Cassar
vs
Koperattiva All 4 One

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

          Final               Decree         2955

05/06/2012

GWU
vs
British Pensions Office within British High Commission​

Financial compensation schemes following termination of employment

G.B.C.

          Final               Decree         2966

12/06/2012

Alfrida Camilleri Borg
vs
St. Edward's College

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

          Final               Decree         2960

15/06/2012

Sabrina Aguis
vs
RTK Ltd.

Discriminate treatment

L.C.

          Final               Decree         3002

15/06/2012

Sabrina Aguis
vs
RTK Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

       2157        Final

25/06/2012

Maurice Zammit
vs
Crampac Ltd​

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2158
Final

27/06/2012

Saviour Caruana
vs
John's Garage Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2159
Final

28/06/2012

Alfred Brincat
vs
Foster Clark Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

         Final                Decree        3003

28/06/2012

Patrick O'Brien
vs
Overland Malta (Trading) Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

         Final                Decree         2710

06/07/2012

Khaled Baely
vs
Methode Electronics Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2160
Final

10/07/2012

Shaun Bonello 
vs
HSBC plc.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2161
Final

16/07/2012

Sonia Debrincat
vs
Xlendi Hotel Co. Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2162
Final

16/07/2012

Carmel Vella
vs
Gozo Aluminium Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2163
Final

16/07/2012

Katerina Skleranova
vs
Verdala International School

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2164
Final

16/07/2012

Saviour Giordano
vs
Grand Harbour Marina plc.​

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.​​

         Final                Decree         2977

16/07/2012

Mary Rose Cesare
vs
Pantera Hotels Co. Ltd.
 et

​Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

         Final                Decree         2978

16/07/2012

Carmen Fenech
vs
Pantera Hotels Co. Ltd.
 et

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

         Final                Decree         2979

16/07/2012

Grace Debono
vs
Pantera Hotels Co. Ltd. et​

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

         Final                Decree         2980

16/07/2012

Joan Sciberras
vs
Pantera Hotels Co. Ltd. et

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

         Final                Decree         2981

16/07/2012

Tessie Compton
vs
Pantera Hotels Co. Ltd. et

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2165
Final

23/07/2012

Pierre Mizzi
vs
Casino Maltese

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

        Final         Decree
2975

24/07/2012

Glenn Pace
vs
Delta (Malta) Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2166
Final

25/07/2012

UHM
vs
Awtorita Trasport f'Malta

Performance Bonus Payment to Tally Clerks

M.F.

2167
Final

01/08/2012

Kenny Debono
vs
Water Services Corporation

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2168
Final

01/08/2012

Mario Sammut
vs
Joseph Camilleri

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2169
Final

05/09/2012

Micheal Schembri
vs
Mizzi Motors

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

         Final                Decree         3034
  

04/09/2012

Maria Zammit
vs
Vivian Corp. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

        Final             Decree      3010 

04/09/2010

Nicholas Ripard
vs
Global Capital plc.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2170
Final

17/09/2012

Anthony Falzon
vs
Silver Shadow

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2171
Final

17/09/2012

Mary Cassar
vs
Madre Christina Kannangara

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

        Final              Decree      2990

17/09/2012

Josette Zrinzo
vs
Dolceria Italiana Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.A.

2172
Final

18/09/2012

Roderick Camilleri
vs
Polidano Group

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2173
Final

19/09/2012

Maria Theresa Bartolo
vs
Conservatorio Vincenzo Bugeja

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2174
Final

20/09/2012

Jean Paul Schembri
vs
Ta' Qali Producers

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

        Final             Decree     2735

25/09/2012

Charlene Vella
vs
Banif Bank plc.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

         Final               Decree      2827

27/09/2012

Carmel Vella
vs
Gozo Aluminium Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2175
Final

28/09/2012

George Abela
vs
Faith Garage

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2176
Final

03/10/2012

Clement Azzopardi
vs
Farmers' Central Co-Operative

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2177
Final

03/10/2012

Nigel Dunkerley
vs
European Pilot Academy Ltd. et

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

         Final                Decree        3046

05/10/2012

Guido Zammit
vs
Vassallo Concrete Services

Unfair Dismissal

M.G.

         Final              Decree     3017

05/10/2012

Clayton Cuschieri
vs
Island Sightseeing Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

         Final              Decree     3018

05/10/2012

Brian Grech
vs
Island Sightseeing Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

         Final               Decree     2976

09/10/2010

Gerald Mifsud
vs
Arriva Malta Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2178
Final

10/10/2010

GWU
vs
Tug Malta Ltd.

Union Recognition

F.M.

         Final                Decree       3052

22/10/2012

Marquita Muscat 
vs
Go plc

Unfair Dismissal

M.G.

2179
Final

22/10/2012

Angele Licari
vs
Nuance Group Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

         Final              Decree     2827

24/10/2012

Carmel Vella 
vs
Gozo Aluminium Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

         Final              Decree     3024

05/11/2012

Martin Cassar
vs
Foundation for Shelter & Support to Migrants

Unfair Dismissal

C.A.

2180
Final

12/11/2012

Paul Bugeja
vs
Alberta Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

G.B.C.

2181
Final

15/11/2012

Noileen Zammit
vs
Inspire

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

         Final                Decree       3037

16/11/2012

Jurgen Schilde
vs
Novitas Ltd.

Discriminatory Treatment

V.V.

2182
Final

20/11/2012

Gaetano Micallef
vs
Foster Clarks Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2183
Final

21/11/2012

Simon Copperstone
vs
Help online Services Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2168
Interpretation

27/11/2012

Mario Sammut
vs
Joseph Camilleri

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2184
Final

26/11/2012

Somchai Falzon
vs
Gafa Gateway Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2185
Final

27/11/2012

Alex Lia
vs
Dragonara Resort Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2186
Final

29/11/2012

Vanessa Brincat
vs
Cassar Weaving Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2187
Final

04/12/2012

Stephen Spiteri
vs
Malta Freeport

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

         Final              Decree      3060

04/12/2012

Aleandro Pace
vs
G4S Security Services

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

2188
Final

05/12/2012

Neil Attard
vs
Globe Ground Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2189
Final

06/12/2012

Christianne Borg
vs
Fimbank plc

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2190
Final

07/12/2012

Grezzju Azzopardi
vs
PBS Ltd

Alleged Breach in equal renumeration

J.B.

2191
Final

07/12/2012

Anthony Carabott
vs
BIM Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

         Final              Decree     3009

10/12/2012

Bisrat Gebregergs
vs
John Cordina

Unfair Dismissal

C.A.

2192
Final

11/12/2012

Veronica Vassallo
vs
Nuance Group Malta Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

          Final               Decree        2854

12/12/2012

Aklilu Gudetta
vs
AX Holdings

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

 Final
       Decree        2982

17/12/2012

Jessica Vassallo
vs
Scotts Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

         Final               Decree      3025

20/12/2012

Sherif Hardy
vs
Playmobil Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

         Final             Decree     3073

20/12/2012

Taiye P. Oladotum
vs
Marsaxlokk FC​​​​​

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.​​​

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​