2013 Decisions





* Chairpersons :

A.Deg. - Anthony Degiovanni
E.T. - Edmund Tabone
F.M. - Franco Masini
G.B.C. - George Borg Cardona
H.W. -  Harold Walls
J.B. - Dr. Joseph P. Bonnici LLD
L.C. - Dr. Leslie Cuschieri LLD
M.F. - Dr. Martin Fenech LLD
M.G. - Mary Gaerty
C.A. - Chris Attard
J.H. - Joan Haber
C.C. - Charles Cassar
V.V. - Dr. Vanessa Vella LLD
J.P. - James Pearsall
Y.M.S. - Dr. Yana Micallef Stafrace
K.B.C. - Dr. Katrina Borg Cardona
C.C.G. - Dr. Charmaine Cristiano Grech

 

Decision  Number &​ Type​​

Date​

​Parties​​​

Subjec​t

Chairperson*

2193
Fi​nal

09/01/2013

​Patrick Aguis
vs
Support Services Ltd.

U​nfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2194
Final

09/01/2013

Brian Bonnici
vs
Island Hotels Group Ltd. et

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

Final Decree
3063

15/01/2013

Berhanu Molla Bedane
vs
Dewfresh Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

2195
Final

18/01/2013

Dr.Brian Azzopardi
vs
MCAST

Alleged resignation from employment's contract

V.V.

Final Decree
3068

23/01/2013

Albert Muscat
vs
Arriva Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

Final Decree
3015

25/01/2013

Daphne Vella
vs
Tumas Gaming Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2196
Final

25/01/2013

Alfred Farrugia
vs
SeaMalta Co. Ltd.

Alleged Discriminate Treatment

J.B.

2197
Final

25/01/2013

Thomas Clinch
vs
AirMalta plc.

Alleged Discriminate Treatment

J.B.

2198
Final

25/01/2013

Doris Sammut
vs
Gafa's Saveway Cleaning Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2199
Final

25/01/2013

Janice Vassallo
vs
Gafa's Saveway Cleaning Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2200
Final

25/01/2013

Saviour Sammut
vs
Gafa's Saveway Cleaning Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.B.

2201
Final

30/01/2013

Robert Cini
vs
Cube Relocations Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

Final Decree
3041

31/01/2013

Raymond Brincat
vs
Vince Gatt et

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

2202
Final

06/02/2013

Andrea Genovese
vs
Extra Low Voltage Engineering Services Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

Final Decree
3084

08/02/2013

Joanne Mifsud
vs
Azmi Clach et

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

2203
Final​

12/02/2013

John Vindigni et
vs
Medserv Operations Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2204
Preliminary

19/02/2013

GWU
vs
British High Commission

Union Recognition for Bargaining purposes

J.H.

2205
Final

20/02/2013

Alexandra Fenech
vs
Segretarjat Edukazzjoni Nisranija

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2206
Final

21/02/2013

Clint Agius
vs
JF Security

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2207
Final

26/02/2013

Josette Cassar
vs
MMDNA

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2208
Final

28/02/2013

Robert Carfagno
vs
42 Telecom Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

M.G.

2209
Final

04/03/2013

GWU 
vs
PBS

Payments

L.C.

2210
Final

04/03/2013

Marie Padovani
vs
Foster Clark Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2211
Preliminary

07/03/2013

Marzia Bruno
vs
Maxxcom Ltd​

Unfair Dismissal

M.G.

2212
Final

13/03/2013

Lydia Borg
vs
Cuschieri Bros Aluminium Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2213
Final

13/03/2013

Noel Celeste
vs
Jeamik Lifts Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

Final Decree
3035

14/03/2013

Raiza Savona
vs
Methode Ltd​

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

2214
Preliminary

15/03/2013

Janika Spiteri
vs
MCAST

Alleged Abuses

V.V.

Final Decree
3064

18/03/2013

Sandro Zahra
vs
Bay Street Shopping Complex

Unfair Dismissal

C.A.

Final Decree
3036

18/03/2013

John Bonavia
vs
Arriva Malta Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

C.A.

2215
Final

21/03/2013

Eric Micallef
vs
Bezzina Maritime Services

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2216
Preliminary

25/03/2013

Alessandro Bruno
vs
GVC New Ltd et

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

Final Decree
3049

26/03/2013

GWU
vs
Malta Enterprise​

Early Retirement Schemes

C.C.

2217
Final

27/03/2013

Petra Stock
vs
Carre Aviation Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

Final Decree
3045

03/04/2013

Mary Rose Vella
vs
Merit Precision Tools Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

Final Decree
3109

15/04/2013

Danielle Cordina
vs
MITA

Discriminatory Treatment

L.C.

2218
Final

29/04/2013

Stephen Chircop
vs
Malta Freeport Terminals

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2219
Final

30/04/2013

Carmelo Agius
vs
Antione Tanti​

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

Final Decree
3105

02/05/2013

Eugenio Sultana
vs
Island Hotels Group

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2220
Final

06/05/2013

Chantelle Conti
vs
Pizza by Luca Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.A.

2221
Final

06/05/2013

Joseph Zammit
vs
Fondazzjoni Wirt Artna
  

Unfair Dismissal

C.A.

Final Decree
3110

07/05/2013

Nicola Sansone
vs
HSBC

Unfair Dismissal

C.A.

2222
Final

13/05/2013

Yvette Borg
vs
Aero Nautical Services Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2223
Final

15/05/2013

Mario Spiteri
vs
Gasan Mamo Ins. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2224
Final

15/05/2013

Anthony Darmanin
vs
BIM Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2225
Final

16/05/2013

Ray Borg
vs
Advanced Telecommunications Systems Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.G.

2226
Final

16/05/2013

Joanna Attard
vs
Carre Aviation Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.G.

Final Decree
3107

16/05/2013

Antionette Falzon
vs
Arriva Malta Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

Final Decree
3074

21/05/2013

MUBE
vs
HSBC

Disagreement on Salesforce & Sales Management Agreement

J.H.

2227
Preliminary

23/05/2013

Chris Cachia
vs
Melita plc

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2228
Final

27/05/2013

John Vassallo
vs​
Emmanuel Vella & Sons Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

Final Decree
3095

29/05/2013

Joseph Demmanuele
vs
OS Riding Equipment Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

Final Decree
2847

31/05/2013

Joseph Dimech 
vs
Tug Malta Ltd.​

Discriminatory Treatment

J.B.

2229
Final

04/06/2013

Maria Debono
vs
Foster Clark Products​

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2230
Final

11/06/2013

Veneranda Mangani
vs
Vella Falzon Bldg Supplies Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

2231
Final

11/06/2013

Sharon Grixti
vs
Dragonara Gaming Ltd.

Alleged Breach of Article36 chapter 452

L.C.

2232
Final

13/06/2013

Daniel Damato
vs
Oiltanking Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

Final Decree
3053

19/06/2013

Andre Cassar
vs
Miles Express Cargo Systems

Unfair Dismissal

J.H.

2234
Final

25/06/2013

Emmanuel Farrugia
vs
Brincat Bros

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2235
Final

25/06/2013

David Farrugia
vs
Brincat Bros

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

Final Decree
2989

27/06/2013

GWU
vs
Dragonara Gaming Ltd

Tips to Gaming Attendants

E.T.

Decree
2951

02/07/2013

Joseph Scerri
vs
BPC International Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

A.Deg.

2236
Final

16/07/2013

Christinus Harvey
vs
British High Commission Malta

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

Final Decree
2786

18/07/2013

Eileen Said
vs
Education Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2237
Preliminary

24/07/2013

Lucia Baranda Serna
vs
Glimmer Ltd et

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

Final Decree
3115

28/08/2013

Aaron Tabone
vs
Arriva Malta Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

Y.M.S.

Final Decree
2915

28/08/2013

GWU
vs
Transport Authority

Union Recognition

E.T.

Final Decree
3124

04/09/2013

Andrew Borg
vs
Macpherson Med Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.G.

Final Decree
2923

19/09/2013

GWU
vs
PlayMobil​

Written Warning/Charge

H.W.

2238
Final

19/09/2013

Thomas Abela
vs
Preluna Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2239
Final

23/09/2013

Paul Mizzi
vs
Windmill Co. Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2240
Final

23/09/2013

Henry Mifsud
vs
Atlas Tool Co.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2241
Final

24/09/2013

Louisana Brincat 
vs
St. Martin's Institute of IT

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

Final Decree
3093

27/09/2013

G4S
vs
GWU/UHM

Redundancies

C.C.G.

Final Decree
3040

30/09/2013

GWU
vs
BOV plc

Early Retirement Scheme

C.C.

Final Decree
2998

30/09/2013

GWU
vs
Palumbo Shipyard​

Union Recognition

L.C.

2242
Final

02/10/2013

Emmanuel Pace 
vs
YP Marketing Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2243
Partial

08/10/2013

Antionette Calleja
vs
Contracts' Dept. DG

Discriminatory Treatment

L.C.

2244
Final

08/10/2013

Joe Vella
vs
Seabank Catering Co.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2245
Final

08/10/2013

Louis Zammit
vs
Seabank Catering Co.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

Decree
966

15/10/2013

Lino Debono
vs
Malta Drydocks​

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2246
Final

15/10/2013

Frank Cassar
vs
St.James Hospital​

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2247
Final

16/10/2013

Chris Dimech
vs
Globe Ground Malta Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2248
Final

16/10/2013

Ivan Sciberras
vs
BPC International Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2249
Final

16/10/2013

Joe Scerri
vs
BPC International Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

Decree
3138

18/10/2013

GWU
vs
Tug Malta

Right for re-negotiation

J.P.

2250
Final

21/10/2013

GWU
vs
Malta Shipbuilding Co.

Implimentation of Clause 3.5 - June 2000 Agreement

M.F.

Final Decree
3151

21/10/2013

GWU
vs
Nuance Group

Disciplinary Action

M.F.

Final Decree
3164

21/10/2013

Anna Navarro
vs
Simonds Farsons plc​

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

Final Decree
3120

22/10/2013

Brady Sammut
vs
Norbert Camilleri

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

Final Decree
3112

24/10/2013

Martin Galea
vs
Gozo Press​

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2251
Final

29/10/2013

Josanne Cassar
vs
Standard Publications Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

Final Decree
3127

31/10/2013

Barbara Szentmarjay
vs
Wagerlogic Malta Software Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

Final Decree
3135

31/10/2013

Odette Sammut
vs
Baystreet Holdings Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2252
Final​

08/11/2013

Marco Briffa
vs
Mosta Local Council

Unfair Dismissal

K.B.C.

Final Decree
2817

26/11/2013

Stephen Johnston
vs
Melita plc​

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2253
Final

27/11/2013

Arriva Ltd
vs
GWU

Payment to scheduled Workers  on Public/National Holidays

C.C.

2254
Final

02/12/2013

Joseph Caruana
vs
Suncrest Hotel

Unfair Dismissal

Y.M.S.

2255
Final

03/12/2013

Ronald Azzopardi
vs
Roosendaal Hotels Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2256
Final

04/12/2013

Charles Borg
vs
Dragonara Gaming Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

Decree
2946

04/12/2013

Ruth Vella
vs
Margaret Borg

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2257
Final

11/12/2013

Dr Victor Zammit
vs
Euris Consult Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2258
Final

12/12/2013

Ingrid O'Brien
vs
De La Salle College

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

Final Decree
3129

16/12/2013

Emmanuel Spearing
vs
MCL Components Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.​