2014 Decisions



* Chairpersons :

E.T. - Edmund Tabone
F.M. - Franco Masini
H.W. -  Harold Walls
L.C. - Dr. Leslie Cuschieri LLD
M.F. - Dr. Martin Fenech LLD
C.C. - Charles Cassar
J.P. - James Pearsall
Y.M.S. - Dr. Yana Micallef Stafrace
K.B.C. - Dr. Katrina Borg Cardona
C.C.G. - Dr. Charmaine Cristiano Grech

 

Decision Number & Type

Date

Parties

Subject

Chairperson*

2259
Final

07/01/2014

Victor Spiteri
vs
Pisciculture Marine De Malte Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2260
Final

08/01/2014

Anthony Vassallo
vs
Joseph Debono

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

    Final      Decree
3163

13/01/2014

David Bajada
vs
Multi Packaging Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2261
Final

16/01/2014

Paul McKenna
vs
de Vere & Partners Holding

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2262
Final

16/01/2014

GWU
vs
MTA

Transfer of H.Galea

C.C.G.

    Final      Decree
3173

16/01/2014

BOV
vs
MUBE/GWU

Union Recognition

C.C.G.

2263
Final

17/01/2014

David Fenech
vs
Paradise Bay Hotel

Unfair Dismissal

K.B.C.

    Final      Decree
3140

22/01/2014

Micheal Schembri
vs
Bajja Investments Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

    Final      Decree 
2852

22/01/2014

Gordon Fino Grixti
vs
St. Patrick's School

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2264
Final

22/01/2014

Lawrence Hili
vs
Melita Marine Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2265
Final

27/01/2014

John Cutajar
vs
MDD et

Discriminatory Treatment

M.F.

2266
Final

28/01/2014

Owen Schembri
vs
Nylon Knitting Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2267
Final

28/01/2014

Joseph Galea
vs
Universita ta' Malta

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2268
Final

29/01/2014

Gordon Grixti Fino
vs
St. Patrick's School

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2269
Final

03/02/2014

Philip Camilleri
vs
Bortex Clothing

Constructive Dismissal

Y.M.S.

2253
Interpretation 

05/02/2014

Arriva Ltd
vs
GWU

Disagreement on payment to workers scheduled to work on Public/National holidays

C.C.

2270
Final

07/02/2014

Reuben Friggieri
vs
Impact Real Estate et

Unfair Dismissal

K.B.C.

2271
Final

11/02/2014

Dr.M.Brincat for Diego Righi
vs
Emerald Shipping Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2272
Final

20/02/2014

Veronique Amato Gauci
vs
EMD Services Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2273
Final

20/02/2014

Lorna Camilleri
vs
Bajja Investments Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

  Final    Decree
3005

25/02/2014

Joseph Vella
vs
BOV plc

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2275
Final

03/03/2014

Dr.Anika Psaila Savona
vs
CHI Ltd.

Discriminatory Treatment

M.F.

2276
Final

06/03/2014

Mario Muscat
vs
Windmill Aluminium Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2277
Final

12/03/2014

Sergio Ciantar
vs
STMicroelectronics

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

    Final     Decree
2788

13/03/2014

Joseph Bonello
vs
Grid Trading Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2278
Final

17/03/2014

Marilyn Galea
vs
American International Contractors Inc.

Redundancy

Y.M.S.

2279
Final

25/03/2014

Chris Cachia
vs
Melita plc

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2280
Final

26/03/2014

Aaron Cauchi
vs
Alf Mizzi & Sons et

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2281
Final

27/03/2014

Kathleen Barlow
vs
Pentasia Malta Co Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2282
Final

02/02/2014

Raycine Cassar
vs
Accreda Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2283
Final

04/04/2014

Antonella Mamo
vs
Office Group Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

  Final    Decree
3203

08/04/2014

Etienne Borg Ferranti
vs
Meeting Point Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.G.

   Final    Decree
3065

09/04/2014

Nadia Erasmus George
vs
St.Micheal Foundation for Education

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2284
Final

10/04/2014

Emmanuel Grogan
vs
Wembley Motors Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2285
Final

06/05/2014

Victor Borg
vs
AirMalta plc.

Discriminatory Treatment

L.C.

  Final    Decree
2848

14/04/2014

Rita Azzopardi
vs
Connections Caterers Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

Decree
3159 Prt1

23/04/2014

Dr. Ivan Sammut
vs
NSFX Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

Decree
3159 Prt2

23/04/2014

Dr. Ivan Sammut
vs
NSFX Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2286
Final

07/05/2014

Peter Tabone
vs
Marco Gauci

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2287
Final

07/05/2014

Joanna Pullicino
vs
Kunsill Malti ghax-Xjenza

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

  Final    Decree
2482

10/06/2014

GWU
vs
IPSL

Sick Leave

L.C.

Dezert
2628

16/05/2014

GWU
vs
Playmobil Ltd.

Breach in Collective Agreement

M.F.

Dezert
2871

16/05/2014

Mary Grace Barbara
vs
St Microelectronics

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

Dezert
2203

16/05/2014

MUMN
vs
Zammit Clapp Hospital

Recognition for services rendered in previous years in Govt's Hospitals

M.F.

Dezert
2588

16/05/2014

Carmel Borg
vs
Sovereign Hotels

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.G.

Dezert
2708

16/05/2014

Richard Warr
vs
Sunderlands Online Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.G.

Dezert
2723

16/05/2014

Lucianne Camilleri
vs
Playmobil Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.G.

Decree
3145

21/05/2014

William Brydon
vs
Dennis Filigree Work Co Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2288
Final​

09/06/2014

Richard Manning
vs
Wheels Yachting Ltd
.

Unfair Dismissal

Y.M.S.

Dezert
3020

10/06/2014

Membo Kipasa
vs
Prestige Travel Marketing Co. Ltd
.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

  Final    Decree
3237

16/06/2014

Alison Bone Casha
vs
Seasus Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.G.

  Final    Decree
3194

18/06/2014

Rachel Caruana
vs
Scotts Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

K.B.C.

2289
Final

19/06/2014

Roberta Spiteri
vs
ST Microelectronics

Work of equal value

C.C.G.

2290
Preliminary

20/06/2014

Andre' Pizzuto
vs
Housing Authority

Unfair Dismissal &
Discriminatory treatment

K.B.C.

2291
Final

25/06/2014

Marsina Gatt
vs
Euston Co. Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2292
Final

01/07/2014

Glenn Desira
vs
Alberta Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2293
Final

02/07/2014

Emmanuel Scicluna
vs
Fruitland Co Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2294
Final

02/07/2014

Vanessa Fenech
vs
SL Ship Management Co Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

2295
Final

03/07/2014

Raphael Bourgeois
vs
Eden Hospitalitiy Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2296
Final

07/07/2014

Dennis Farrugia
vs
Westin Dragonara Resort

Unfair Dismissal

M.F.

2297
Final

08/07/2014

John Farrugia
vs
MaltaPost plc

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2298
Final

14/07/2014

GWU
vs
BOV

Alleged breach in procedures re promotions

M.F.

   Final    Decree
3099

21/07/2014

Vanessa Attard
vs
Awtorita ghat-Trasport

Discriminatory Treatment

M.F.

2299
Final

23/07/2014

Stephen Scicluna
vs
Nylon Knitting Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2300
Final

29/07/2014

UHM
vs
MIA

Salaries' relativity & responsibilities of Met Officers

L.C.

2301
Final

31/07/2014

Roberta Balzan
vs
Maltapost plc

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.G.

  Final    Decree
3226

01/08/2014

Paolo Cannistraro
vs
Aria Chartering Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

   Final    Decree
3227

01/08/2014

Elda Busalacchi
vs
Aria Chartering Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

   Final    Decree
966

01/08/2014

Lino Debono
vs
Malta Drydocks

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2302
Final

06/08/2014

Jean Pierre Camilleri
vs
Arriva Malta Ltd.

 

Unfair Dismissal

 

F.M.

2303
Final

06/08/2014

Ramona Zammit
vs
Paradise Bay Hotel

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

  Final    Decree
3245

17/07/2014

Bernard Meidl
vs
MB Services Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

K.B.C.

   Final    Decree
3246

31/07/2014

Euchar Baldacchino
vs
Cardinal Health Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

K.B.C.

Dezert
3117

20/08/2014

Marcello Meilaq
vs
JF Security Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

  Final    Decree
2792

04/09/2014

Louis Jones
vs
Pater Holding Co. Ltd.

Payment of Gratuity on Redundancy

C.C.G.

  Final    Decree
3232

05/09/2014

Daniele Tagliarini
vs
Marine & Industrial Consultancy Services Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2304
Final

09/09/2014

Anthony Paris
vs
Emm. Delicata Winemakers Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2305
Final

16/09/2014

Angela Vassallo
vs
Milano Due Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal & Discriminatory treatment

L.C.

2306
Final

01/10/2014

Bernard Schranz
vs
Energeia Industries

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

  Final    Decree
3185

01/10/2014

George Buttigieg
vs
Alhambra Trading

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2307
Preliminary

02/10/2014

MUBE
vs
BOV plc

Union Recognition

H.W.

2308
Final

03/10/2014

Lee Fresle
vs
Westminister Properties Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

K.B.C.

  Final    Decree
3256

07/10/2014

Carmel Carbonaro
vs
Malta Freeport Co.

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2309
Final

09/10/2014

Charmaine Scicluna Muxi
vs
Spinola Development Co
.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.G.

2310
Final

08/10/2014

Nelly Ramorasata
vs
Aragon International Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

F.M.

  Final    Decree
3114

09/10/2014

Steve Zammit et
vs
Airmalta plc.

Deduction in Salaries

C.C.G.

   Final    Decree
3133

09/10/2014

Abigail Vella et
vs
Airmalta plc.

Deduction in Salaries

C.C.G.

2311
Final

14/10/2014

Emanuel Ciantar
vs
MCE Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

L.C.

2312
Final

15/10/2014

Lara Boffa
vs
Philip Toledo Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

J.P.

2313
Final

15/10/2014

Francesco Farrugia
vs
Arriva Malta Ltd
.

Unfair Dismissal

 

F.M.

 

2314
Final

16/10/2014

Eucharist Bezzina
vs
M.D.P. Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

H.W.

2315
Final

20/10/2014

BOV
vs
MUBE et

Union Recognition

M.F.

  Final    Decree
3253

22/10/2014

Donald Scerri
vs
Exante Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

Y.M.S.

2316
Final

22/10/2014

Elvira Stoyanova Nenkova
vs
Agriculture Co-op Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.

2317
Final

23/10/2014

Ashley Bondin
vs
Louisa Cesare

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2318
Final

23/10/2014

Zorica Stevanovic
vs
MCUK Ltd.

Unfair Dismissal

C.C.G.

  Final    Decree
3225​
​27/10/2014

Capt. Andre Van Delzen​
vs
Mediterranean Aviation Co. Ltd.

​Unfair Dismissal M.F.​
2319
Final
​28/10/2014 Martin Vella
vs
Dolphin Industrial Services Ltd.
​Unfair Dismissal ​L.C.
2320
Final
​04/11/2014 Martin Caruana
vs
Joyce Darmanin
Matthew's Bar and Restaurant
​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
2321
Final
​05/11/2014
Ethel Spiteri
vs
Primebet International Ltd.
​Unfair Dismissal F.M.​
2322
Final
05/11/2014​

Tania Gaffiero
vs
Gafa Saveways Ltd.​

​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
​2323
Final
​06/11/2014 Albert Falzon vs Melita Mobile Limited​​ ​Unfair Dismissal C.C.G.​
​2324
Final
06/11/2014​ Joseph Baldacchino vs F.S. Engineering and Plastics Limited​ ​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.G.
   ​Final    Decree
3134
​06/11/2014 Patrick Cassar
vs
Stop Shop Arcade Ltd.​
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.G.​
2325
Preliminary​
​07/11/2014 Natasha Catherine Farrugia
vs
Cars International  Ltd.
​Unfair Dismissal K.B.C.​
  Final    Decree
3021​
10/11/2014​ Transport Malta
vs
UHM​
​Interpretation or change of agreement ​Y.M.S.
Decree
3108​
12/11/2014​
Christopher Rizzo
vs
Corinthia Construction (Overseas) Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal J.P.​
  Final    Decree
3145
​12/11/2014​ William George Brydon
vs
Dennis Filigree Work Co Ltd
​Unfair Dismissal J.P.​
2326
Final
​13/11/2014 Irene Desira
vs
Inspire – the Eden and Razzett Foundation
​Unfair Dismissal and Alleged Discrimination ​C.C.G.
2327
Final
​13/11/2014 Marisa Camilleri
vs
Malta International Airport plc.
​Alleged Demotion ​​C.C.G.
Decree
2938
18/11/2014​ Aften Schembri et
vs
Playmobil Malta Ltd
​Unfair Dismissal L.C.​
   Final    Decree
3159​​
26/11/2014​ ​Dr. Ivan Sammut
vs
NSFX Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.P.
2328
Final
​27/11/2014 Katja Hoeher
 vs
Palazzo Events Limited
​Unfair Dismissal H.W.​
2329
Final​
1/12/2014​ Anita Cassar Bellizzi vs
San Raffael Pharmacy
​Unfair Dismissal Y.M.S.​
2330
Final​
1/12/2014​ Anthony Mansueto
vs
Multigas Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal M.F.​
2331
Final
​4/12/2014 Christopher Cardona vs
Malta Dairy Products Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal E.T.​
​2332
Final
4/12/2014​ GWU
vs
Enemalta Corporation​
​​
​Payment of suspended employees following industrial action F.M.​
2333
Final​
9/12/2014​ Glenn Spiteri et alia vs
Korporazzjoni Enemalta
​Alleged Discrimination. Principle of Equal pay for Equal work ​L.C.

2334
Final​

10/12/2014​ Alessandro Bruno
vs
GVC New Ltd. and Gaming VC Corp. Ltd
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.​
2335
Final
11/12/2014​ Jessica  Pisani
vs 
Medialivecasino Ltd ​
​Unfair Dismissal F.M.​
2336
Final​
​19/12/2014 Edward Vella
 vs
Arriva Malta Ltd, et al
Reinstatement to former position L.C.​
2337
Final​
19/12/2014​ Alexander Schembri
vs
Arriva Malta, et al
Reinstatement to former position ​L.C.