2015 Decisions




* Chairpersons :

E.T. - Edmund Tabone
F.M. - Franco Masini
H.W. -  Harold Walls
L.C. - Dr. Leslie Cuschieri LLD
M.F. - Dr. Martin Fenech LLD
C.C. - Charles Cassar
J.P. - James Pearsall
Y.M.S. - Dr. Yana Micallef Stafrace
K.B.C. - Dr. Katrina Borg Cardona
C.C.G. - Dr. Charmaine Cristiano Grech 


Decision Number & Type

Date

Parties

Subject

Chairperson*

2338
Final

08/01/2015

Charlene Polidano
vs
Gafa Saveway Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2339
Final

08/01/2015

Daniela Nappa Licari
vs
Gafa Saveway Ltd

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2340
Final

08/01/2015

Diana Spiteri
vs
Gafa Saveway Ltd​

Unfair Dismissal

E.T.

2341
Final
​13/01/2015
Stefan Caruana
vs
Island Sightseeing Limited
 ​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​L.C.
2342
Final
​14/01/2015 ​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
2343
Final
​14/01/2015 Stephanie Micallef
vs
Media Games Malta (EU) Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
​2344
Final
​14/01/2015 Raisa Savona
vs
Media Games Malta (EU) Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​F.M.
2345
Preliminary​
​16/01/2015 Hakki Cosgun
vs
Leo Gove
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
Final Decree
2889​
​19/01/2015 ​Carmel Cremona
vs
Enemalta Corporation
​Discriminatory Treatment ​M.F.
Final Decree
2890
​19/01/2015 Joseph Farrugia
vs
Enemalta Corporation​
​Discriminatory Treatment M.F.​
Final Decree
2891
19/01/2015​ Dorianne Diacono
vs
Enemalta Corporation
​Discriminatory Treatment ​M.F.
Final Decree
2892​
​19/01/2015 Catherine Ellul
vs
Enemalta Corporation
​Discriminatory Treatment M.F.​
Final Decree
2893​
​19/01/2015 Helen Calamatta
vs
Enemalta Corporation​
​Discriminatory Treatment ​M.F.
Final Decree
2894
​19/01/2015 ​Ivan Pisani
vs
Enemalta Corporation
​Discriminatory Treatment M.F.​
Final Decree
2895
​19/01/2015 ​Eric Cachia
vs
Enemalta Corporation
​Discriminatory Treatment ​M.F.
Final Decree
2896
19/01/2015​ Joseph Pace
vs
Enemalta Corporation
​Discriminatory Treatment M.F.​
Final Decree
2897
​19/01/2015 Chris Galea
vs
Enemalta Corporation​
​Discriminatory Treatment ​M.F.
Final Decree
2898
​19/01/2015 Charles Magro
vs
Enemalta Corporation
​Discriminatory Treatment ​M.F.
Final Decree
2899
19/01/2015​ Anthony Rocco
vs
Enemalta Corporation​
​Discriminatory Treatment M.F.​
Final Decree
2900​
​19/01/2015 Vanessa Cachia Bugeja
vs
Enemalta Corporation​​
​Discriminatory Treatment ​M.F.
2346
Final
​21/01/2015 Vincent Zahra
vs
Integrated Business Systems Ltd​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.P.​
2347
Final
21/01/2015​
Tanya Grigorova Delcheva
vs
Dragonara Beauty Clinics Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
​2348
Final
​22/01/2015
Fiona Spiteri
vs
Oxford House Limited​
​​Alleged Discrimination C.C.G.​
Final ​Decree
2752
​26/01/2015 ​Antoine Portelli
vs
Smart City Malta Ltd​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​M.F.
Final Decree
3319
​28/01/2015 ​Jennifer Mangion
vs
Island Resorts Company Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal L.C.​
2349
Final
​29/01/2015 Joseph Cutajar
vs
Combino Pharm (Malta) Ltd​​
​Principle of Equal Pay for Equal Work  C.C.G.​
2350
Final
​29/01/2015 Joseph Pawney
vs
Combino Pharm (Malta) Ltd​​

​Principle of Equal Pay for Equal Work  C.C.G.​​
​2351
Final
​29/01/2015 Mandy Micallef
vs
Combino Pharm (Malta) Ltd​​​

Principle of Equal Pay for Equal Work ​ ​C.C.G.​
​2352
Final
​29/01/2015 Stephen Farrugia
vs
Combino Pharm (Malta) Ltd​​

​Principle of Equal Pay for Equal Work  C.C.G.​​
​2353
Final
​29/01/2015 ​Kevin Ellul
vs
Combino Pharm (Malta) Ltd​​

​Principle of Equal Pay for Equal Work  C.C.G.​​
2354
Final​
​29/01/2015 ​Lee Wingfield
vs
Combino Pharm (Malta) Ltd​​​

​Principle of Equal Pay for Equal Work  ​C.C.G.​
​2355
Final
​29/01/2015 ​Rita Bonello
vs
Combino Pharm (Malta) Ltd​​

Principle of Equal Pay for Equal Work ​ ​C.C.G.​
​2356
Final
​29/01/2015 ​Malcolm Sacco
vs
Combino Pharm (Malta) Ltd​​

​Principle of Equal Pay for Equal Work  ​C.C.G.​
​2357
Final
​29/01/2015 Maria Caligari
vs
Combino Pharm (Malta) Ltd​​

​Principle of Equal Pay for Equal Work  ​C.C.G.​
2358
Final
​29/01/2015 Dona Galea
vs
Combino Pharm (Malta) Ltd​​​​​
​Principle of Equal Pay for Equal Work  C.C.G.​​​
Dezert
3048
​29/01/2015 Donalise Chircop
vs
Dimar Shipping Agency Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​Y.M.S.
​2359
Final
​30/01/2015 Simon Borg
vs
Playmobil Malta Ltd​
Discriminatory Treatment​ K.B.C.​
2360
Final
​02/02/2015 ​Mark Farrugia
vs
Ricasoli Tank Cleaning Limited​
​Discriminatory
Treatment
​​M.F.
​2361
Final
​04/02/2015 ​Lucia Baranda Serna
vs
Glimmer Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
​2362
Preliminary
​11/02/2015 ​UHM
vs
Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Ltd​
Union Recognition​ ​F.M.
​2363
Final
​13/02/2015 ​John Dougall
vs
Go Plc
​​Discriminatory
Treatment
​K.B.C.
Final Decree
3307
​13/02/2015 ​Miriam Ebejer
vs
Sunseeker Malta Ltd​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​K.B.C.
2364
Final
​17/02/2015 Carmel ​sive Charles Borg
vs
L-Ambaxxata Franciza f' Malta​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​L.C.
2365
Final
​17/02/2015 Mario Pirotta
vs
Corinthia Construction (Overseas) Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal L.C.​
2366
Final​
​18/02/2015 Jesmond Nappa Licari
vs
Malta Freeport Terminals Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​​ ​​F.M.
2367
Preliminary
​18/02/2015 Sandra Fenech
vs
Dar Pirotta​
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.P.
​2368
Final
​19/02/2015 ​Josette Mifsud
vs
Gafa Saveway Ltd​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​E.T.
Final Decree
3191
​25/02/2015 ​Hakki Cosgun
vs
Leo Gove​
Unfair Dismissal​ K.B.C.​
Final Decree
2772
​03/03/2015 ​Sylvana Farrugia
vs
Malta International Airport plc​

​Unfair Dismissal
Y.M.S.​
​​2369
Final
​05/03/2015 Latha Shony
vs
Paragon Ltd
Unfair Dismissal ​E.T.
Final Decree
3166
​05/03/2015 Lorraine Cassar
vs
Malta Public Trnasport Services (Operations) Ltd
Unfair Dismissal​ ​H.W.​
​Final Decree
3328
10/03/2015
Jessica Brincat
vs
Valletta Gateway Terminals Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​L.C.
2370
Final
​11/03/2015 Ashraf Jarbo
vs
Peak Leisure Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
2371
Final
​11/03/2015 David Calleja
vs
Peak Leisure Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
2372
Preliminary
​11/03/2015 Michael Warrington
vs
FCM Bank Ltd​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.P.
​2373
Final
​13/03/2015 Nadya Borg Busuttil
vs
Maltco Lotteries Ltd
Unfair Dismissal​ ​K.B.C.
​2374
Final
​13/03/2015 Donald Vella
vs
Valletta Fund Services Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​Y.M.S.
​2375
Final
​23/03/2015 ​Marisa Attard
vs
Id-Dar tal-Providenza​
Unfair Dismissal​ M.F.​
​2376
Preliminary
​26/03/2015 Gianfranco Selvaggi
vs
Malta University Holding Company​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​K.B.C.
​2377
Final
​26/03/2015 ​Nathania Mifsud
vs
Sterling Holdings Company Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.G. ​
Final Decree
3351
​26/03/2015 Ita Francis
vs
St. George's Football Club​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​E.T.
​2378
Preliminary
08/04/2015 ​Jonathan Azzopardi
vs
AAT Medical Ltd
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
​Final Decree
3224
​09/04/2015 ​Beverly Anne Trim
vs
Panopera Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.G.​​
2379
Final​
​14/04/2015 ​Antoinette Vella
vs
Care Malta Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​L.C.
Final Decree
3282​
​15/04/2015 Sandra Fenech
vs
Dar Pirotta​
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.P.
2380
Final
​21/04/2015 Joseph Zammit
vs
Jonathan Callus
​Unfair Dismissal L.C.​
2381
Final​
​24/04/2015 ​James Buhagiar
vs
Jani Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
2382
Final
​04/05/2015 Kurt Fenech
vs
Pavi Supermarket​
​Unfair Dismissal ​M.F.
​2383
Final
​06/05/2015 General Workers Union
vs
Playmobil Malta Ltd​​
​Trade Dispute ​J.P.
​2384
Final
​06/05/2015 Maria Dorianne Darmanin
vs
Yellow Pages (Malta) Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.P.​
2385
Final
​07/05/2015 Malta Freeport Terminals Ltd
vs
General Workers Union
and
Union Haddiema Maghqudin​
​Trade Dispute E.T.​
2386
Final
​08/05/2015 Muiris Seasmus Mahon
vs
GOAGT Limited
and
Maritime Guard Group Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
2387
Final
​11/05/2015 Jean Sebastian Beets
vs
S4L Group Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​M.F.
Final Decree
3329
​12/05/2015 ​Rebecca Ellul
and
Wesley Ellul
vs
Stella Maris College​
​Unfair Dimissal ​F.M.
2388
Final​
​14/05/2015 Alastair Cuschieri
vs
Cateressence Ltd
and
Oper8Malta Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal ​E.T.
2389
Preliminary​
​18/05/2015 ​Basak Kristin Degirmenci
vs
Jimmy Aquilina
​Unfair Dismissal ​Y.M.S.
2390
Final​
​19/05/2015 Jean-Pierre Ellul
vs
Antoine Tanti​
​Unfair Dismissal​ ​H.W.
​2391
Final
​19/05/2015 Joseph Azzopardi
vs
Antoine Tanti
​Unfair Dismissal​ ​H.W.
​2392
Final
​19/05/2015 Christine Azzopardi
vs
Antoine Tanti​
​​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
2393
Final​
​19/05/2015 James Vassallo
vs
The Eden Foundation
and
The Eden Co-Operative Society Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ L.C.​
​2394
Final
​26/05/2015 Dione Tedesco
vs
F. Cordina & Sons Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal H.W.​
​2395
Final
​28/05/2015 Kevin Cerullo
vs
GOAGT Limited
GOAGT (UK) Limited
AR2M Ltd
and
Maritime Guard Group Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.G.
Final Decree
3314
​28/05/2015 ​Philip Ciantar
vs
Peppino's Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
​2396
Final
​04/06/2015 Darren Cilia
vs
FIM Property Investments Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.G.​
Final Decree​
3216
​08/06/2015 Michael Rizzo
vs
Aramex (Malta) Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal M.F.​
​2397
Partial
​09/06/2015 Mark Muscat
vs
HSBC Bank Malta plc​
​Discriminatory Treatment
L.C.​
​Final Decree
3243
​11/06/2015 Jennifer Cefai
vs
Prohealth Ltd​
Unfair Dismissal​ K.B.C.​
​2398
Final​
​12/06/2015 Anthony Debono
vs
Actavis Ltd​​
Unfair Dismissal​ K.B.C.​​​
Final Decree
3295​
​17/06/2015 Anthony Degiovanni
vs
The Nuance (Group) Malta Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
Final Decree
3285​
​25/06/2015 Anna Maria Collison
vs
Marenco Investments Ltd.
​Unfair Dismissal ​Y.M.S.
​Final Decree
3170
​25/06/2015 ​Alison Sultana
vs
Supreme Travel Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.G.
Final Decree
3030​
​30/06/2015 ​Edward Bugeja
vs
Greenstar Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​Y.M.S.​
Final Decree​
3067
​06/07/2015 George Farrugia
vs
Transport Malta​
​Discriminatory Treatment
M.F.​
Final Decree​
3111
​07/07/2015 ​MUBE
vs
Bank of Valletta p.l.c​
.
Trade Dispute​ ​C.C.
2399
Final
​10/07/2015 Marzia Bruno
vs
Maxxcom (Malta) Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
​2400
Final
​13/07/2015 GWU
vs
Bank of Valletta plc
​Trade Dispute ​M.F.
​2401
Final
​15/07/2015 Charlo Briffa
vs
Styles Apertures Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
​2402
Final
​22/07/2015 ​Michael Agius
vs
Tek-Moulds Engineering Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
2403
Final
​28/07/2015 Louis Camilleri
vs
Waldorf Auto Services Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
​2404
Final
​10/08/2015 Giulio Spampinato
vs
Enetsport Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ M.F.​​
​Final Decree 3375 ​12/08/2015 ​Johann Agius
vs
Vodafone Malta Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.P.
​2405
Final
​03/09/2015 ​Joseph Azzopardi
vs
Planit Travel Services Ltd​
Unfair Dismissal​ F.M.​
2406
Final​
​17/09/2015 ​Maria Dolores Grima
vs
Malta Memorial Distinct Nursing Association (MMDNA)​
​Unfair Dismissal ​E.T.
Final Decree
3339​
​18/09/2015 Jonathan Azzopardi
vs
AAT Medical Ltd​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​C.C.
Final Decree
3251​
​28/09/2015 Roberto Rosario Anastasi
vs
Joeviv Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​Y.M.S.
​2407
Preliminary

30/09/2015
Vincent Camilleri
vs
SS lifts Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
​Final Decree 3366 ​30/09/2015 ​David Agius
vs
Betfair Holding (Malta) Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.P.
2408
Final​
​01/10/2015 ​Victor Vella
vs
Joseph Buhagiar​
​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
​2409
Preliminary
​05/10/2015 ​Massimiliano Bani
vs
Highland Lassie Limited
and
Idroj Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​M.F.
​Final Decree
3177
​05/10/2015 Sean Tabone
vs
Associated Equipment Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​Y.M.S.
​Final Decree
3189
​05/10/2015 ​Sue Nani
vs
EC Meetings Company Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
Final Decree
3300
​05/10/2015 ​Alessandro Amatulli
vs
Paul Tonna Son of Santu Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal ​M.F.​​
​Final Decree
3342
​06/10/2015 Dr Jonathan Abela Fiorentino noe
vs
Jetmagic Air Personnel Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​​L.C.
Final Decree
3248​
​09/10/2015 Michael Mifsud
vs
Jani Ltd​
​Unfair Dismisssal ​K.B.C.
2410
Final​
​12/10/2015 Nathalie Chetcuti
vs
Director General (Planning and Priorities Division) within the Ministry of European Affairs and Implementation of the Electoral Manifesto
and
​Director General (Funds and Programmes Division) within the Ministry of European Affairs and Implementation of the Electoral Manifesto
and
Permanent Secretary within the Ministry of European Affairs and Implementation of the Electoral Manifesto
and
Director Corporate Services within the Ministry of European Affairs and Implementation of the Electoral Manifesto
and
Attorney General
and
Government of Malta
​Alleged breach of Fixed Term Contracts ​Y.M.S.
​Final Decree 3257 ​12/10/2015 ​Mario Debono
vs
Sky Gourmet Malta Inflight Ltd
and
Sky Gourmet Malta Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
3376
Decree
​15/10/2015 ​Vincent Camilleri
vs
SS Lifts Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
​Final Decree
3398
​15/10/2015 Alan Formosa
vs
Saint John's Insurance Limited
Reed Treasury limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​C.C.G.
2411
Final
​20/10/2015 Charles Tonna
vs
Riviera Resort Limited
Meeting Point Hotel Management (Malta) Limited
​Allegation of Breach of Equal Pay for Equal Work ​L.C.
2412
Final
​21/10/2015 ​Judith Overand nee` Attard Mccarthy
vs
Med Reef Company Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.​
2413
Final
​30/10/2015 Eileen Leone Ganado
vs
Link School of Languages​
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
Final Decree 3363 ​30/10/2015 ​Gabriella Zammit
vs
Il-Mithna Restaurant Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
2414
Final
​03/11/2015 ​David Martin
vs
Goldvest Company Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
​2415
Preliminary
​05/11/2015 ​Johan Briffa
vs
Bay Street Holdings Limited
Bay Street Hotel Complex Limited​​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
​2416
Final
​10/11/2015 ​Mina Rylander
vs
White November Corporate Services (Malta) Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​L.C.
Final Decree  3202 ​13/11/2015 ​Andre Pizzuto
vs
Housing Authority
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
Final Decree  3369 ​13/11/2015 ​John Baptist Chetcuti
vs
6pm Limited
and
Compunet Operations Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
Final Decree 3378​ ​16/11/2015 ​Eden Leisure Group Limited
vs
Neil Darmanin
​Unfair Dismissal ​M.F.
2418
Final​
​18/11/2015 Dennis Francalanza
vs
HSBC Bank (Malta) plc​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.P.
​2417
Final
​18/11/2015 Joseph Mifsud
vs
Pater Holding Co. Ltd.
and
U.C.I.M. Co. Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
​2419
Final
​19/11/2015 Gaston Caruana
vs
Maltco Lotteries Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal ​E.T.
Final Decree 3320 ​23/11/2015 Gordon Falzon
vs
More Supermarkets (Hamrun) Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​Y.M.S.
​2420
Final
​30/11/2015 ​General Workers' Union
vs
Bank of Valletta plc​
​Trade Dispute ​M.F.
​2421
Final
​02/12/2015 Karl Grech
vs
Lighthouse Innovations Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
Final Decree  3317 ​02/12/2015 ​Yulia Debattista
vs
Streamlogue Services Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
2422
Final​
​11/12/2015 ​Daniel Scicluna
vs
Inspirations Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
2423
Final​
​15/12/2015 James Spiteri
vs
Lufthansa Technik Malta​
​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​