2018 Decisions


* Chairpersons :

C.C. - ​Charles Cassar
C.C.G - Dr. Charmaine Cristiano Grech
D.P. - Doreen Parnis
E.T. - Edmund Tabone
F.M. - Franco Masini
G.V. - Dr. Geoffrey Vella
H.W. - Harold Walls
J.D. - Joseph Delia
J.H.P. - James H. Pearsall​
K.B.C. - Dr. Katrina Borg Cardona​​
M.F. - Dr. Martin Fenech LLD​
R.A.M. - Richard A. Matrenza


Decision Number & Type​​​​​ ​​​Date​ Parties​​ Subject
Chairperson*
2503
Final
02/01/2018 Christian Sciberras
vs
Multi Packaging Limited​

Unfair Dismissal F.M.
​Final Decree 3489 09/01/2018​ Paul Zahra
vs
Phoenicia Hotel Company Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​​D.P.
Final Decree
3557
10/01/2018​ ​Pierre Mangion 
vs
SR Technics Malta Limited​

​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment ​C.C.G.
​Final Decree 3529 15/01/2018​ Gabriella Grech
vs
​Bathroom Designs Ltd.​

Alleged Discriminatory Treatment and Unfair Dismissal​
K.B.C.​
​​Final Decree 3545 16/01/2018​ Dr. Christine Calleja as a special mandatory of Christophe Guiraud
vs
Shadow Aviation Solutions Limited​

​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
2504
Final
17/01/2018​ Irene Gauci
vs
​Creative Refurbishing Centre (Malta) Ltd.​​
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.​
2505
Final​
​24/01/2018 Ellen McGratten
vs
​Centrecom Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.G.​
Final Decree 3583 ​25/01/2018 Edward Chilton
vs
Bonnici Brothers Services Ltd​.​

Unfair Dismissal​ ​​J.D.
2506
Final​
31/01/2018​ Joseph G. Pace
vs
​Ving Insurance Brokers Ltd. and
DAN Europe Foundation​

Unfair Dismissal​ F.M.​​
​2507
Final
01/02/2018​ Marcus Thomlinson
vs
deVere & Partners Holding Ltd.​​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​E.T.
2508
​Final
12/02/2018​ Christopher Schembri
vs
Joseph Farrugia 
o.b.o.
Midice Services & Supplies Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal​ ​​J.H.P.
​​2509
Preliminary
14/02/2018​ Antoinette Farrugia
vs
​Optical (CCSG) Company Limited
and
Classic Group​

​Unfair Dismissal C.C.​
Final Decree
3274​
​19/02/2018 Natasha Homer Early
vs
​Guts Gaming Ltd.​
Alleged Discriminatory Treatment and Unfair Dismissal​​​ ​G.V.
​​2510
Preliminary
21/02/2018​ Malcolm Refalo
vs
​​​Ramelene Office Supplies  Ltd​.​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​J.H.P.
2511
Final​
​23/02/2018 Giannella Mifsud
vs
​Bishop’s Conservatory Secondary School
and
Christine Scerri​

Unfair Dismissal​ ​​K.B.C.
2512
​​Final
​26/02/2018 ​​Doreen Camilleri
vs
The European Union Programs Agency​
Alleged Discriminatory Treatment and Victimisation​ ​M.F.
2513
Final
​01/03/2018 Adv. Dr Andrew Borg-Cardona on behalf of Mr Toufic Yafaoui 
vs
FIMbank plc​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​J.D.
​Final Decree 3451 13/03/2018​ ​Marco Camilleri
vs
Malta International Airport plc​​

Unfair Dismissal​ ​D.P.
Final Decree 3600 ​15/03/2018 Nadia Camilleri
vs
GIG Central Services Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​J.D.
Final Decree 3548 ​21/03/2018 Christopher Haber et
vs
Lufthansa Technik Malta Limited​​
Alleged Infringement of the Principle of Equal Value Work​ ​C.C.G.
2514
Final​
21/03/2018​ ​Sammy M. Hazzouri​
vs
Joseph Formosa and Jesmond Formosa as the proprietary of St Elias Pharmacy​​

​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
Final Decree 3617 22/03/2018​ Christopher Briffa
vs
J. Calleja Import & Export Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​H.W.
2515
Final
​26/03/2018 Wyatt Zammit
vs
Roosendaal Hotels Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​J.H.P.
2516
Final
26/03/2018​ ​​Emmanuel Theuma
vs
Auto Buses De Leon (Transport Malta)
and the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Capital Projects​
Alleged Abusive Behaviour​ ​M.F.
Final Decree 2812 ​26/03/2018 Mary Carmen Bajada
vs
Bank of Valletta plc​
Alleged Discriminatory Treatment and Victimisation​​
M.F.​
Final Decree 3128 ​27/03/2018 Kevin Fenech
vs
Enemalta Corporation​
​​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment G.V.​
2517
Final
27/03/2018​ Salama Abdellatif
vs
CareMalta Ltd.​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​H.W.
2518
Final​
04/04/2018​ Paolo Cannistraro
vs
Aria Chartering Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​F.M.
2519
Final
04/04/2018​ Elda Francesca Busalacchi
vs
Aria Chartering Limited​

​Unfair Dismissal ​​F.M.
2520
Preliminary​
​04/04/2018 Waldemar David Galea
vs
University of Malta​
​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
2521
Preliminary​
​05/04/2018 Mr. Sammy M. Hazzouri vs
Mr Owen Falzon
and
Mrs Arlette Falzon Seychell
for San Filippu Pharma Ltd​​
.​
Unfair​ Dismissal ​​J.D.
2522
Final​
09/04/2018​ Sergio Ciantar
vs
ST Microelectrics (Malta) Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ M.F.​
2523
Final​
09/04/2018​ Assiba Hetchat
vs
Air x Charter Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​M.F.
Final Decree 3629​ ​10/04/2018 ​Ismaila Diagne​
vs
1. Cherry Ltd.
 2. Playcherry Ltd.
3. Cherry Malta Limited
4. Cherry Gaming Limited
5. Come On Malta Limited
6. Co-Gaming Limited
7. Cherry AB PUBL​
 
Unfair Dismissal​ ​C.C.
Dezert
3372
12/04/2018​ Dr George Sapiano as special mandatory of the absent Martin Huff
vs
Sensus Capital Markets Ltd​.​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​G.V.
​2524
Final
​12/04/2018 Ian Falzon
vs
Malta Transport Authority​
​Unfair Dismissal ​E.T.
​Final Decree 3553 ​16/04/2018 Michael Buttigieg
vs
​1. ​ Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Limited
and
2. Malta Public Transport Services Limited​
 
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.H.P.
2525
Final
16/04/2018​ Neville John Stewart Wyllie
vs
​Maitland Malta Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​J.H.P.
2526
Final
​16/04/2018 Josephine Attard Sultana
vs
Tony Zarb (General secretary of the GWU) et​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​M.F.
Final Decree 3236​ ​16/04/2018 Christian Camilleri
vs
John Borg, as practicing the trade ​on behalf of 'International Sales Direct'​

​Unfair Dimissal M.F.​
​​2527
Preliminary
​18/04/2018 Anna Zawistowska
vs
BML Group Ltd.​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​C.C.
Final Decree 3616 ​27/04/2018 Luz Mery Garcia Piedrahita
vs
​Gaming Innovation Group p.l.c.​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​K.B.C.
Final Decree 3630​ 09/05/2018​ Mandy Giordmaina
vs
Hili Properties Ltd.​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​E.T.
2529
Final​
09/05/2018​ Marthese Borg
vs
Dougall Tobacco Manufacturing Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.
​2530
Final​
​15/05/2018 Martha Rawe
vs
Nathalie Briffa Farrugia noe​
​Unfair Dismissal ​D.P.
2531
Final
18/05/2018​ Gianfranco Selvaggi
vs
Malta University Holding Co Ltd.​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​K.B.C.
Dezert
3183
18/05/2018​ ​Adam John Muscat
vs
GVC New Limited​

Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.G.​
Dezert
3497
18/05/2018​ Edward Degaetano​
vs
Malta Industrial Parks that with the decree dated 23 June 2017 it was called into the cause the Malta Enterprise​​

 Alleged Injustice ​C.C.G.
2532
Final
22/05/2018​ Olga Polak
vs
United Car Rental and Leasing Ltd.​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​G.V.
Final Decree 3258 ​23/05/2018 Claude Sammut
vs
Shireburn Software Limited​
​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​E.T.
2533
Final​
25/05/2018​ Le Jean Coetzee
vs
​Culross Global Investment Management Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​R.A.M.
Final Decree 3609 28/05/2018​ Adrian Attard
vs
Bavarian Technology Systems PComm64​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​J.H.P.
2534
​​Final​
29/05/2018​ Christian Grech
vs
International Trading Company Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​H.W.
2535
Final​
01/06/2018​ ​Lotta Malmberg
vs
Fortis Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​K.B.C.
Final Decree 3396 ​04/06/2018 UHM o.b.o and in the interest of its members: Patricia Grima, Miriam Saia, Marthese Baldacchino, Odette Spiteri, Margaret Cassar, Raphael Bonnici and Leanne Mizzi, all MEPA employees
vs
Malta Environment and Planning Authority​​
relating to the Industrial Tribunal to decide that MEPA should provide an effective, appropriate and fair remedy, to the listed UHM members, after the Board of Appeal was found in their favour
​K.B.C.
2536
Final
05/06/2018​ Josianne Gafa
vs
Eden Leisure Group Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​H.W.
​Final Decree
3631
05/06/2018​ Daniel Thornton
vs
Co-Gaming Limited​

​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
Dezert
3472
​14/06/2018 Raymond Portelli
vs
​MaltaPost plc​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​J.D.
​​2537
Final
14/06/2018​ Giorgio Caschetto
vs
The General Soft Drinks Co. Ltd.​​​
Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
2538
Final
15/06/2018​ Leonard Camilleri
vs
Polidano Brothers Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​K.B.C.
2539
Final
​28/06/2018 George Mario Attard​
vs
MCAST​​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.D.​
2540
Final
03/07/2018​ Ivan Curmi
vs
Sports Malta​​
Contestation of a Warning​ ​G.V.
2541
Final
04/07/2018​ Victoria Dougall
vs
Diane Abela personally and as a practitioner in the trade as Ganza Shopping Centre​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.
Final Decree
3290
16/07/2018​ ​Captian Massimiliano Bani
vs
Highland Lassie Limited
and
Idroj Limited​

​Unfair Dismissal ​M.F.
2542
Final​
​17/07/2018 ​Brian Farrugia
vs
Arkadia Marketing Ltd​

​Unfair Dismissal ​​D.P.
​2543
Final
17/07/2018​ Stephen Briffa
vs
Arkadia Marketing Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​D.P.
2544
Final
19/07/2018​ Roxanne Delmar
vs
George and Marlene spouse Grech,
carrying on business as Grefed Worldwide Trading​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​E.T.
​​2545
Final
20/07/2018​ Etienne Azzopardi
vs
Joseph Vella in his own name and as carrying on business under the name of Ambassador Service Station & Tyres Services​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​K.B.C.
Final Decree 3632 ​24/07/2018 Jonathan Micallef et
vs
Air Malta p.l.c.
and
the Union of Cabin Crew Members​
Regarding Alleged Discrimination and Breach of the Principle of an Equal Pay for Equal Work​ ​G.V.
Final Decree 3632 ​26/07/2018 ​Jonathan Micallef et 
vs
Air Malta p.l.c.
and
the Union of Cabin Crew Members​
Regarding Alleged Discrimination and Breach of the Principle of an Equal Pay for Equal Work​ G.V.​
​Final Decree 3632 ​​26/07/2018​ Jonathan Micallef et 
vs
Air Malta p.l.c.
and
the Union of Cabin Crew Members​
​​
Regarding Alleged Discrimination and Breach of the Principle of an Equal Pay for Equal Work​​​ ​​G.V.​​
​Final Decree 3632 26/07/2018​ Jonathan Micallef et 
vs
Air Malta p.l.c.
and
the Union of Cabin Crew Members​​​
​​
​Regarding Alleged Discrimination and Breach of the Principle of an Equal Pay for Equal Work​​​ ​​​G.V.​​
2546
Final​
27/07/2018​ Roger Debono
vs
Gozo Hotels Company Limited​
 
​Unfair Dismissal ​​K.B.C.
Final Decree 3392 ​30/07/2018 Stephan Heilmann
vs
Tipico Co Ltd​​
.​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​G.V.
​2547
Final
​30/07/2018 Marco Pisani
vs
The Av Warehouse​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​M.F.
Final Decree 3463 11/09/2018​ Joseph Brincat
vs
City Security Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​R.A.M.
2548
Final
11/09/2018​ Aldo Scicluna
vs
Zahra Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​G.V.
2549
Final​
18/09/2018​ Ryan Joseph Bonnici
vs
Pavi Supermarkets Ltd.​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​H.W.
2550
Final
27/09/2018​ Angel Barbara
vs
Treasure Breaks Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​E.T.
Final Decree 3606​ 02/10/2018​ ​Diana Todorova
vs
Mildura Catering Company Limited​​​

​Unfair Dismissal H.W.​
​​2553
Final
08/10/2018​ Kennith Buttigieg
vs
Enemalta Corporation​​
Regarding Alleged Discrimination ​M.F.
2554
Final​
​08/10/2018 Marco Pulo
vs
Enemalta Corporation​​
​Regarding Alleged Discrimination ​M.F.
2555
Final
08/10/2018​ Charles Carabott
vs
Enemalta Corporation​
​Regarding Alleged Discrimination M.F.​
2556
Final​
08/10/2018​ Emmanuel Quattromani
vs
Enemalta Corporation​
Regarding Alleged Discrimination ​M.F.
2557
Final
09/10/2018​ Deomede Cassar
vs
Director General of Operations within the Ministry for Education and Employment​
Regarding Alleged Injustice​ G.V.​
Final Decree 2983 10/10/2018​ Roberta Spiteri
vs
ST Microelectronics (Malta) Ltd​.​
Regarding Alleged Breach of the Principle of an Equal Pay for Equal Work​​​​ G.V.​
​​2558
Final
11/10/2018​ Claudia Micallef
vs
​De La Rue Currency & Security Print Ltd.​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​J.D.
​Final Decree 3676 ​17/10/2018 Simon Grunke
vs
​Web International Service Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.
Final Decree 3534
22/10/2018​ Maria Sabina aka Sabina Scicluna
vs
AWAS (Agency for the Welfare of Asylum Seekers)​​​
Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​ ​M.F.
2559
Preliminary
​25/10/2018 Mazen Dadouch​
vs
Imam Muhammed El Sadi
in representation of Mariam Al Batool School​​​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.D.​
2560
Final
29/10/2018​ Jennifer Camilleri
vs
Stainless Steel Products Limited​

Unfair Dismissal​ ​​J.H.P.
2561
Final
08/11/2018​ Mariette Estefan Arenas
vs
AR Management Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​E.T.
2562
Final
20/11/2018​ Publius Davison​​
vs
De La Rue Currency and Security Print Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ D.P.​
Dezert 3568 ​26/11/2018 ​​Dino Vino
vs
Fino Manufacturing Ltd​.​

Unfair Dismissal​ ​F.M.
2563
Final​
28/11/2018​ Paul Lia
vs
Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.
Dezert
3252
04/12/2018 ​ Basak Kristin Degirmenci
vs
Jimmy Aquilina practicing the trade named 'Jimmy's Pastizzeria'​​​
​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment and Unfair Dismissal​ ​G.V.
2564
Final​
04/12/2018​ Melissa Grech
vs
Sierra Stationery & Bookshop Ltd.​​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​D.P.
2565
Final
05/12/2018​ Christine Cauchi Cole
vs
Software Projects 16 Ltd​.​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​F.M.
2566
Final
05/12/2018​ ​Christopher Zammit Dimech
vs
Cherry Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal​ ​C.C.G.
2567
Preliminary
​05/12/2018 ​Saviour Attard
vs
Palm City Limited​

​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.G.
Final Decree
3687
​10/12/2018 Theresa Fenech
vs
Chamber College (Malta) Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​J.H.P.
Final Decree 3123 ​14/12/2018 Aaron Aquilina
vs
Air Malta p.l.c.​
​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​ ​M.F.
Final Decree
3182
​17/12/2018 Paul Abdilla
vs
Yellow Pages (Malta) Ltd.​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.

 

 ​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​