2019 Decisions



* Chairpersons :

A.M. - Dr. Anna Mallia
C.C. - ​Mr. Charles Cassar
C.C.G. - Dr. Charmaine Cristiano Grech
D.P. - Ms. Doreen Parnis
E.T. - Mr. Edmund Tabone​
F.M. - Mr. Franco Masini
G.V. - Dr. Geoffrey Vella
H.W. - Mr. Harold Walls
J.D. - Mr. Joseph Delia
J.G. - Mr. Joseph Gerada​​​
J.H.P. - Mr. James H. Pearsall
M.D. - Dr. Marouska Debono
M.F. - Dr. Martin Fenech
R.A.M. - Mr. Richard A. Matrenza


​​
​​Decision Nu​mber & Type Date​ P​arties​ Subject Chairperson*
2568
​Final
​08/01/2019 ​Priscilla Falzon
vs
Maltapost plc​

Unfair Dismissal​ ​​G.V.
Final Decree 3493 ​08/01/2019 Luis Baltonado
vs
Chilipay Ltd.​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.
Final Decree 3466
10/01/2019 Joseph Calleja
vs
St. Andrew’s Farm and Building Co. Ltd.​​

Unfair Dismissal C.C.
Final Decree 3607 ​10/01/2019 Rita Mifsud
vs
Mellieħa Holiday Centre​
​Alleged Injustice and Acts of Victimisation. C.C.G.​
2569
Final​
14/01/2019​ Michael Warrington
vs
FCM Bank Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal J.H.P.​
Final Decree 3350 15/01/2019​ Peter Spence
vs
Digisec Media Limited​
 ​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​H.W.
Final Decree 3690 16/01/2019​ ​Nurhak Delen
vs
Evolution Malta Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.
2570
Final​
​17/01/2019 Patrick Calleja
vs
Marina San Ġorġ Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​E.T.
2571
Final
21/01/2019​ Charmaine Vassallo
vs
Jesmond Tonna​
Alleged Unfair Dismissal and Sexual Harassment​ ​M.F.
2572
Final​
21/01/2019​ Debra Else
vs
Co-op Trading Company Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​M.F.
2573
Final​
​24/01/2019 ​Carmen Abela
vs
Centro Management Ltd.​
​Unfair Dismissal ​E.T.
2574
Final
28/01/2019​ David Mercieca
vs
Enemalta Corporation​
​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment ​​M.F.
Final Decree 3355 04/02/2019​ Michael Long
vs
Oiltanking Malta Ltd.​

​Unfair Dismissal ​​M.F.
Final Decree 3694 ​08/02/2019 Marianne Dalli
vs
Kevin Briffa
and
Evan Camilleri​​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
Final Decree
3452
11/02/2019​ Mario Zerafa
vs
Air Malta p.l.c.​​
Alleged Disriminatory Treatment​ M.F.​
Final Decree 3181 18/02/2019​ Natasha Catherine Farrugia
vs
Cars International Limited​
​​​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​A.M.
​​2575
Preliminary
​19/02/2019 Christopher Mifsud
vs
Giana G Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​​ ​D.P.
2576
Final​
27/02/2019​ Giada Mifsud Calabro’
vs
Union Print Company Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal​​ F.M.​
2577
Preliminary
​28/02/2019 Marlene Busuttil
vs
Healthmark Care Services Ltd.​
     ​
​Unfair Dismissal​ ​E.T.
Final Decree
3720
05/03/2019​ Sylvana Zahra
vs
​Alf Mizzi & Sons (HR) Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​M.D.
2578
Final​
​06/03/2019 ​George Borg
vs
Ultimate Technology Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.
Final Decree 3586 06/03/2019​ Joan Bonnici
vs
Raketech Group Limited​​​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​R.A.M.
Final Decree 3681 ​07/03/2019 Bernard Xuereb
vs
Islands Hotels Limited and
for any interest that may have Corinthia Group of Companies and Corinthia Hotels Limited and after the minutes dated 27.11.2018 shall read Corinthia (Malta) Limited Staff Services​​
Regarding the Breach of Contract Conditions​ ​G.V.
2579
Final
07/03/2019​ ​Salvina sive Silvia Mizzi
vs
Garendon School
and
Mary Carmen sive Marlene Tua in her position as a Principal of the same school​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​H.W.
2580
Final
07/03/2019​ Victoria Walker
vs
Garendon School
and
Mary Carmen sive Marlene Tua in her position as a Principal of the same school​
​Unfair Dismissal H.W.​
2581
Final
07/03/2019​ Vivian Barbara
vs
Garendon School
and Mary Carmen sive Marlene Tua in her position as a Principal of the same school​
​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
2582
Final​
11/03/2019​ ​​Mario Buhagiar
vs
Enemalta Corporation which by the decree dated 30th March 2015 should read as Engineering Resources Limited​
​Alleged Disriminatory Treatment​​ M.F.​
Final Decree
3594
11/03/2019​ Charlot Cassar
vs
Transport Authority (Malta)​​
Alleged Disriminatory Treatment​​ and Unfair Dismissal​ ​M.F.
2583
​Final​
15/03/2019​ Dennis Vella
vs
Dragonara Gaming Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​A.M.
2584
Final​
15/03/2019​ Alfred Agius
vs
Tal-Maghtab Construction Co. Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ A.M.​
Final
Decree
3641
22/03/2019​ Paul Spagnol
vs
Vassallo Builders Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​R.A.M.
Final
Decree
3695
26/03/2019​ Helga Flahive
vs
Sheltons Malta Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​D.P.
Final Decree
3648​
​28/03/2019 ​James Jonathan Perry
vs
Dominion Crew Solutions Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​E.T.
​2585
Final
​28/03/2019 Veronique Amato Gauci
vs
EMD Advisory Services Limited​
 
​Unfair Dismissal ​​J.D.
Final
Decree
3721
​29/03/2019 ​Grace Cilia
vs
University of Malta​
Regarding the failure of the respondents to give effect to themselves with the law on contracts for a definite period​ M.D.​
2586
Final
01/04/2019​ Jonathan Caruana
vs
Malta International Airport p.l.c.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​J.H.P.
2587
Final​
​04/04/2019 John Anastasi
vs
Dr. Martin Balzan in his capacity of President of MAM and also on behalf and in representation of the same Medical Association of Malta (MAM)​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​H.W.
Final
Decree
2389
10/04/2019​ Gardner Bell
vs
Malta International Airport p.l.c.​​
​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​ C.C.G​
Final
Decree
2618​
​10/04/2019 Gardner Bell​
vs
Malta International Airport p.l.c.​​​
​​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​ ​C.C.G.
Final
Decree
3688
10/04/2019​ Mario Mifsud
vs
​Foundation of Co-Cathedral of St John​​
Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​ C.C.G.​
2588
Final
​12/04/2019 Christian Larsson
vs
HeliMalta Ltd.​​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.G.
Final
Decree
3711
​12/04/2019 George Farrugia
vs
Trelleborg Sealing Solutions Malta Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.G.
Final
Decree
3728
​12/04/2019 Giovanni Oddi
vs
DQR-X Limited​
 
Unfair Dismissal​ ​M.D.
Final
Decree
3697
15/04/2019​ Lawyer Stefan Cutajar on behalf and in representation of the absent Youniss Bishar
vs
LAP Suisse-Malta​
 ​
​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
Final
Decree
3685
​15/04/2019 Lawyer Edward Mizzi on behalf and in representation of the absent Murad Haman
vs
LAP Suisse-Malta​​
Unfair Dismissal​ F.M.​
Dezert
3464​
​17/04/2019 Basak Kristin Degremeci and where according to the correction in occhio, made in the decree dated 21 March 2017, the surname should read as Degirmenci
vs
Winunited Limited​
Unfair Dismissal D.P.​
2589
Final
​24/04/2019 Dr. Angele Attard Chetcuti as a special mandatory of Ms. Angela Green
vs
Lufthansa Technik Malta Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.
2590
Final​
24/04/2019​ Gayle Mugliette
vs
Empower Cooperative Limited​​​
​Unfair Dismissal F.M.​
2591
Final
​24/04/2019 Stephen Dimech
vs
Empower Cooperative Limited​​

Unfair Dismissal​ F.M.​
2592
Final
24/04/2019​ Lisa Manduca
vs
Empower Cooperative Limited​
​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​F.M.
2593
Final​
25/04/2019​ Christian Fenech
vs
Alberta Fire & Security Equipment Ltd.​
 
Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
2594
Final​
29/04/2019​ Rodianne Borg
vs
Executive Security Services Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​​​ J.H.P.​
2595
Final
30/04/2019​ Caroline Agius
vs
Lingam Contracting and Design Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ D.P.​
2596
Final​
​30/04/2019 ​Christian Pullicino
vs
Cutajar Ltd.​
Unfair Dismissal​ G.V.​
2597
Final
03/05/2019​ Emanuel Xuereb
vs
San Remo Restaurant Limited​​​
​Unfair Dismissal​​ A.M.​
2598
Preliminary​
​03/05/2019 ​Luke Engerer
vs
International Fashion Co Ltd.,
Bay Street Holding Ltd.,
Bay Street Operations Ltd.
and
Bay Street Hotel Complex​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​R.A.M
2599
Final
03/05/2019​ Sabine Eveline Zapotoczna
vs
Betsson Services Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​R.A.M.
2600
Final​
​03/05/2019 Reuben Psaila​
vs
​​Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Limited
​Unfair Dismissal R.A.M.​
Final
Decree
3552
08/05/2019​ ​Alan Borg
vs
Authority for Transport in Malta​

Alleged Victimisation and Injustices​ C.C.G.​
Final
Decree
3738
09/05/2019​ Kevin Pace
vs
Sambro Service Station Limited​​​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​E.T
2601
Final​
15/05/2019​ Carmel Busuttil
vs
Bezzina Maritime Services Limited​

​Unfair Dismissal​​ C.C.G.​
Final
Decree
3633
16/05/2019​ Joseph Deguara
vs
Mini-Bus CO-OP Ltd​.
and
CO-OP Services Limited​

Unfair Dismissal​​​ ​J.D.
Final
Decree
3740
23/05/2019​ David Brooks
vs
Citadel Insurance p.l.c.​
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.​
2602
Final
​05/06/2019 Nazzareno Galea
vs
V & C Contractors Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.​​
Dezert
3700​
10/06/2019​ Marie Josette Vella Magro
vs
BNF Bank p.l.c.​​
Regarding Constructive Dismissal​ ​C.C.
2603
Final
12/06/2019​ ​​​​Carmel Formosa Holt 
vs
Kane Pisani

Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.​
Final
Decree
3729
13/06/2019​ Sarka Petrikova
vs
Amchara Medical Limited​
​​
Alleged Disriminatory Treatment​​ and Unfair Dismissal​​
M.D.​
Final
Decree
3766
14/06/2019​ UTAC
(Union of Technicals and Clericals)
vs
Planning Authority​
​Regarding an allegation that the proposals for collective agreement for technical and clerical categories are discriminatory ​M.D.
Final
Decree
3652
14/06/2019​ Mathilde Rodriguez-Lognone’
vs
International Translation Agency Limited​

Unfair Dismissal​ R.A.M.​
2604
Preliminary
21/06/2019​ Doreen Saliba
vs
Foster Clark Products Ltd.​​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​J.G.
Final
Decree
3636
27/06/2019​ Stephen Caruana​
vs
Casino Malta Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal ​E.T.
Final
Decree
3662
27/06/2019​ Patience Samsin
vs
Support Services Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
2605
Final​
​09/07/2019 Michelina Bonnici
vs
​Specialist Group Cleaners Ltd.​
 
​Unfair Dismissal​​ H.W.​
2606
Final​
09/07/2019​ Bernard Bezzina
vs
Malta International Airport p.l.c.​​
Unfair Dismissal​​​ H.W.​
2607
​​​Final
11/07/2019​
Unfair Dismissal​​​ ​E.T.
Final
Decree
3762
​15/07/2019 Graziella Mallia
vs
Gilda Company Limited​
Alleged Victimisation
and
Constructive Dismissal​
M.F.​
2608
Final​
15/07/2019​ Andrea Vrazhalska
vs
Ernst & Young Ltd  
and
Ernst & Young Managed Services Ltd.​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.H.P.​
2609
Final
15/07/2019​ Mariano Camilleri
vs
Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Ltd.​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.H.P.​​
2610
Final
15/07/2019​ Joseph Cutajar
vs
Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Ltd.​
 
Unfair Dismissal​ J.H.P.​
Final
Decree
3301
26/07/2019​ Anna Punga
vs
iGame Malta Limited
&
 Shaun O'Neill, whom after the decision of the appeal dated 16/06/2017 was liberated from the observance of the judgement
​Alleged Sexual Harassment and Victimisation​ ​G.V.
Final
Decree
3726​​
​26/07/2019 Nicole Bonello
vs
Content House Limited
​Alleged Constructive Dismissal​ ​M.D.
Final
Decree
3739​
​26/07/2019 Kevin Theuma
vs
University of Malta​
​Alleged alteration of a definite contract to an indefinite one M.D.​
2611
Final
​26/07/2019 Abdulkerim Abagero Abas
vs
Malta Public Transport Services Operations Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal J.G.​
Final
Decree
3475
29/07/2019​ Carlo Fenech
vs
Support Services Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​J.D.
Final
Decree
3743
29/07/2019​ Simon Grima
vs
Fork & Night​
Unf​air Dismissal J.D.​
Final
Decree
3744
29/07/2019​ Mark Grima
vs
Fork & Night​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.D.​
Final
Decree
3592​
​31/07/2019 Kevin Grima
vs
PG Holdings Ltd.
&
PG p.l.c.
&
Pavi Supermarkets Ltd.​
 ​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
Dezert
3639
31/07/2019​ Bernardica Mitic
vs
Mellieħa Holiday Centre Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.G.​​
Final
Decree
3152
09/08/2019​ Saviour Busuttil
vs
Calypso Manufacturing Ltd.​

Unfair Dismissal​ G.V.​
2612
Final​
24/09/2019​ Mark Trapani
vs
Sara Grech Ltd.​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​H.W.
2613
Final​
25/09/2019​ Gregory Sherman
vs
Air X Charter Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.​
2614
Final​
​30/09/2019 Josette Cutajar
vs
John's Garage Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal​ J.H.P.​
2615
Final​
30/09/2019​ ​Plamenov Angelov
vs
Joseph Borg and Sandra Borg,  managing the 'Gym Stars' business and with the decree of 12 December, 2016, which was called into the cause HF Investments Ltd.​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.H.P.​
2616
Final
01/10/2019​ ​Pauline Basile Pace
vs
MFA (Malta Football Association)​
​Unfair Dismissal H.W.​
2618
Final
​03/10/2019 Maria Fenech Attard
vs
AIM Professional Academy Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ H.W.​
2619
Final​
​07/10/2019 Dr. Vito Domenico Benvenga
vs
​Director General Veterinary and Phytosanitary Regulation Division
&
Director Veterinary Regulation Directorate
&
Ministry for the Environment, Sustainable Development and Climate Change​
      ​
​​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment ​M.F.
Final Decree
3773​
​08/10/2019 Alison Fenech
vs
Atom Corporate Services Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
Final
Decree
3779
08/10/2019​ Claudine Mock
vs
Racasse Investments Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.H.P.​
2620
Final
​09/10/2019 Adolf Vella
vs
Sea Port Franchising Ltd.​
Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.G.​
2621
Preliminary​
​09/10/2019 Malta Union of Bank Employees (MUBE)
vs
Bank of Valletta (BOV)​
Regarding payment of wage adjustments for grades where there are Union Members, and this after the Bank entered into an agreement with another union, where these employees in other grades are treated more favorably​ C.C.G.​
2622
Final​
​11/10/2019 Brian Camilleri
vs
Vodafone Malta Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ A.M.​
2623
Final
​11/10/2019 Nathalie Chetcuti
vs
Director General - Planning and Priorities Co-Ordination Division within the Ministry for European Affairs and  the Implementation of the Election Manifesto,  within the Government of Malta
et al​.​
​Alleged Breach of Definite Contract Regulations​ A.M.​
Final
Decree
3670
​28/10/2019 ​Reeta Naz
vs
Support Services Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.H.P.​
Final
Decree
3734
28/10/2019​ Eugen Mischiu
vs
Accounting Services Ltd.​
​Alleged Constructive Dismissal ​M.F.
2624
Final​
29/10/2019​ Joanna Zammit
vs
Stanley Warne​
Unfair Dismissal​ H.W.​
2625
​​​Final​
30/10/2019​ Anthony Attard
vs
Burmarrad Commercials Ltd.​​
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.​
2626
Final​
31/10/2019​ Charlton Calleja
vs
Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Limited  et al. which after the decree dated 15th November 2018, Malta Public Transport Services Limited has to be released from judgement​​
​Unfair Dismissal J.D.​
2627
Final
06/11/2019​ Roderick Azzopardi
vs
Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.G.
Final
Decree
3709
​08/11/2019 Thierry Emmanuel Marie Delor
vs
HOSI Malta Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal J.G.​
Final
Decree
3719
11/11/2019​ Uncle Matts Limited
vs
Jean Pierre Fava​​
M.D.​
2604
Final
12/11/2019​ Andrea Portelli
vs
University of Malta​
Alleged Injustice Suffered by the Applicant​ ​G.V.
2629
Final
21/11/2019​ Simon Peter Zammit
vs
Alex Vella​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​E.T.
Final
Decree
3674
21/11/2019​ Mark Formosa
vs
Permanent Secretary within the Ministry for Gozo
and
Permanent Secretary within the Prim Minister's Office​​
​Unfair Dismissal J.D.​
2630
Final​
22/11/2019​ James Buhagiar
vs
Jani Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​A.M.
2631
Final​
​22/11/2019 Independent Bankers Union - Voice of the Workers
vs
HSBC Bank (Malta) p.l.c.​
Regarding the Representation of the Union Members​ ​A.M.
2632
Final
26/11/2019​ Eduard Roski
vs
Emperor Aviation Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​H.W.
2633
Final
28/11/2019​ George Ebejer
vs
City Sightseeing Malta Ltd.​
Unfair Dismissal​ H.W.​
2634
Final
28/11/2019​ By the decree dated 1st November, 2017, became Anthony Cassar, Josephine Cassar and Darren Cassar for the deceased Cherisse Cassar
vs
Appletree International Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal E.T.​
Final
Decree
3546
28/11/2019​ Jari Pollanen
vs
Arex Services Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal J.D.​
2635
Final
29/11/2019​ ​​​Leibig Peggy as represented by her special attorney, Lawyer Ettiene A. Calleja
vs
Yield Malta Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal J.G.​
2636
Final
03/12/2019​ Antoine Bartolo​​
vs
Worldfone 1 Co. Limited
Unfair Dismissal​ ​D.P.
​2637
Preliminary
03/12/2019​ Adrien Malgonne
vs
​HOSI Malta Ltd
.​
​Regarding that applicant has not received the amount due to him, by the appealing Society 
D.P.​
2638
Final
04/12/2019​ Maria Tereza a.k.a. Tessie Mifsud
vs
FIM Property Investment Limited and FIMBANK p.l.c.​
Alleged Constructive Dismissal​ C.C.​
2639
Final
​04/12/2019 Olusegun Jacob Akanji
vs
Eden Hospitality Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ F.M.​
2640
Final
​04/12/2019 Julia Buckel
vs
Goldfox Enterprises Limited​

Unfair Dismissal​ F.M.​
2641
Final
05/12/2019​ Sarah Spiteri
vs
San Filippu Pharma Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​​E.T.
Final
Decree
3667
26/12/2019​ Giovanni Campa
vs
International Renewable Energy Development Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​F.M.
 

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​