2020 Decisions


* Chairpersons :

A.M. - Dr. Anna Mallia
C.C. - ​Mr. Charles Cassar
C.C.G. - Dr. Charmaine Cristiano Grech
D.P. - Ms. Doreen Parnis
E.T. - Mr. Edmund Tabone​
F.M. - Mr. Franco Masini
G.V. - Dr. Geoffrey Vella
H.W. - Mr. Harold Walls
J.D. - Mr. Joseph Delia
J.G. - Mr. Joseph Gerada​​​
J.H.P. - Mr. James H. Pearsall
M.D. - Dr. Marouska Debono
M.F. - Dr. Martin Fenech
R.A.M. - Mr. Richard A. Matrenza
J.B. - John Bencini​ ​ ​ ​
​​​Decision Number & Type ​​Dat​e ​​Parties​ ​​Subject​ ​Chairperson*
Final
Decree
3612
08/01/2020​ Raymond Camilleri
vs
Malta Public Transport (Operations) Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.​
2642
​​Preliminary​
09/01/2020​ Doctor David Grech
vs
Medicare Services Limited​​
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.G.​
2643
Final​
​09/01/2020 Jacqueline Farrugia
vs
Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
​2644
Final
16/01/2020​ ​​Philip D'Anastasi
vs
Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.D.​
Final
Decree
3767
16/01/2020​ Stephen Kingswell
vs
Ricston Limited​
Alleged Discriminatory Treatment and Constructive Dismissal​ A.M.​
2645
Final​
17/01/2020​ Reuben Friggieri
vs
Impact Real Estate Limited
and
F(Advertising Limited)
and
Owners Best Limited which by the preliminary decision 2270 dated 07th February 2014, both respondent societies, F(Advertising) Limited and Owners Best Investments Limited, ​were released from compliance with the judgment​
​Unfair Dismissal A.M.​
2646
Final​
​24/01/2020 Cher Tonna
vs
CCBill EU Limited​
​Unfair Dismissal J.G.​
Final
Decree
3789​
24/01/2020​ Stephanie Borg
vs
MZ Investment Services Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.G.​
2647
Final
28/01/2020​ Dr. Jeremy Debono on behalf and in representation of the absent Gordon Clark
vs
Dragonara Gaming Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ G.V.
2648
Final​
28/01/2020​ Dr. Jeremy Debono on behalf and in representation of the absent Giancarlo Vecchioni
vs
Dragonara Gaming Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ G.V.​
2649
Final
28/01/2020​ Dr. Jeremy Debono on behalf and in representation of the absent
Andrew Smith
vs​​
Dragonara Gaming Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ G.V.​
2650
Final
​28/01/2020 Stephen Thornton
vs
Dragonara Gaming Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ G.V.​
Final
Decree
3702
28/01/2020​ ​Rowena Fenech
vs
FIMBank p.l.c.​
​Unfair Dismissal D.P.​
Final
Decree
3778
28/01/2020​ Simone Vella
vs
Crane Currency Malta Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ D.P.​
Final
Decree
3479
29/01/2020​ ​Stefano Persiano
vs
Pieta Local Council​
Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​ ​C.C.G.
2651
Preliminary​
30/01/2020​ ​Alfio Borg
vs
The American Embassy of Malta
​Unfair Dismissal J.D.​
2652
Final
05/02/2020​ Maurice Cassar
vs
Juris Klavins​​
Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.​
2653
Final​
05/02/2020​ Joseph Cauchi
vs
Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Ltd.​​
​Unfair Dismissal C.C.G.​
​2654
Final
12/02/2020​  Dr. Adrian Delia as a special agent on behalf and in representation of Dr. Ioannis sive John Katakis, who was absent from these islands and after the minutes dated 15/11/2017, the mandate of Dr. Katakis to be represented by Dr. Adrian Delia is being withdrawn, since Dr. Katakis is now resident in Malta
vs
Maltco Lotteries Ltd.​​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​C.C.
2655
Final
13/02/2020​ Luke Randall Vassallo
vs
Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Ltd.​
Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
2656
Final
​18/02/2020 Malta Union of Bank Employees (MUBE)
vs
Bank of Valletta p.l.c.​​
​Union Recognition H.W.​
​2657
Final
19/02/2020​ ​Emmie Cassar
vs
Port Logistics Operations Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.​
Final
Decree
3768
19/02/2020​ Fernando Scerri
vs
EMCS Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.​
Final
Decree
3689​
20/02/2020​ Aaron Bartolo
vs
Trelleborg Sealing Solutions Malta Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ R.A.M.​
Final
Decree
3742
​21/02/2020 Dr. Ann Marie Mangion as the mandatory of the absent Faye Wareing​
vs
Alea Gaming Ltd.
​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment and Unfair Dismissal M.D.​
Final
Decree
3759
24/02/2020​ Michael Grech
vs
Signal 8 Security Services Malta Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.​
2658
Preliminary
25/02/2020​ Mario Camilleri
vs
G4S Security Services Limited, 
G4S Security Services (Malta) Limited
and
Malta International Airport p.l.c.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ G.V.​
2659
Final​
​27/02/2020 ​Ali Saleban Jama
vs
John Borda on behalf of J & J Scrap Metals​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.D.​
Final
Decree
3348
28/02/2020​ ​Joseph Mercieca
vs
Malta Freeport Corporation Ltd.​
​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment ​A.M.
2660
Final
​28/02/2020 ​Emanuel Mifsud
vs
AX Hotels Operations Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ A.M.​
Final
Decree
3747
​24/03/2020 ​Ayman Khalil
vs
Ergon Projects Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​F.M.
Final
Decree
3796
22/04/2020​ Rebeca Valeria Jimenez Mendoza
vs
Bethard Group Limited​​
​​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment and Unfair Dismissal​ A.M.​
​Final
Decree
3820
03/06/2020​ ​Francisco Perez Delgado
vs
M.C.M. Maintenance Centre Malta Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ H.W.​
Final
Decree
3790
05/06/​2020​ Emanuel Gatt
vs
Alexandra Palace Hotel​​
​Alleged Harassment and Constructive Dismissal ​M.D.
2661
Final​
12/06/2020​ Dorianne Bartolo Vella
vs
Web International Services Limited
​Unfair Dismissal ​J.G.
2662
Preliminary
​12/06/2020 Philippe Jean Guillaut
vs
HOSI Malta Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​J.G.​
Final
Decree
3783
18/06/2020​ Roberto Sacco
vs
Ennio Farrugia on behalf of the Lepeirks Travel Society Ltd.
Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
Final
Decree
3784
18/06/2020​ Joseph Sacco
vs
Ennio Farrugia on behalf of the Lepeirks Travel Society Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
2663
Final
02/07/2020​ Noel Azzopardi
vs
Toly Products Ltd.​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​H.W.
2664
Final​
​09/07/2020 Maria Caruana
vs
GCS Accounting Malta Ltd.​
​Unfair Dismissal   ​F.M.
2665
Final
09/07/2020​ Stephen Spiteri
vs
Malta Freeport Terminals Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ ​F.M.
2666
Final​
​21/07/2020 John sive Ian Azzopardi
vs
APS Bank Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​ H.W.​
​2667
Final
22/07/2020​ Raymond Cassar
vs
Montekristo Direct Ltd.​​
Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.​
2668
Final​
27/07/2020​ Lorenza sive Lora Cascun
vs
Minister for Health
and
Permanent Secretary for the Ministry for Health​​
Unfair Dismissal partially because of a discriminatory measure​ M.F.​
Final
Decree
3674
​​28/07/2020​ Mark Formosa
vs
Permanent Secretary within the Ministry for Gozo
and
Permanent Secretary within the Office of the Prime Minister​​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.D.​
2669
Final​
​11/08/2020 Valery Atanasov
vs
Malta Gaming Authority​​​
Unfair Dismissal​ F.M.​
Final
Decree
3771
17/08/2020​ Kolya Bugeja
vs
Malta Tourism Authority​​
Unfair Dismissal​ J.H.P.​
Final Decree
3371
​26/08/2020 Rosita Seychell
vs
Air Malta p.l.c.​​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​C.C.
Final
Decree
3861
15/09/2020​ Daniela Galea 
vs
Greens Supermarket Ltd ​
Unfair Dismissal​​ D.P​.
Final
Decree
3827
​02/09/2020 Antoine Azzopardi
vs
Gaming Innovation Group p.l.c.
​Unfair Dismissal J.G.​​
Final
Decree
3793
18/09/2020​ Roman Borisov Iliev 
vs
Victoria Bars Limited 
Unfair Dismissal​​ H.W.​
2670
Preliminary​​
​18/09/2020 General Workers Union
vs
Malta Freeport Terminals​​​​
​Union Recognition ​J.G.

2671
Final
23/09/2020​ Aften Schembri et
vs
Playmobil Malta Limited
 
​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​ C.C.G.​
Final
Decree
3817
30/09/2020​ ​Sergio Julian Valverde Jenkins sive Sergio Valverde
vs
Merkur Interactive Malta plc ​
​Unfair Dismissal ​​ C.C.​​​
2673
Final 
01/10/2020​ Aldo Briffa
vs
 Malta Freeport Terminals Limited​​
Unfair Dismissal​​​ ​J.D.​
2672
Final ​
01/10/2020​ Nagihan Ozer
vs
DataLogic Limited ​​​
Unfair Dismissal ​​ ​J.D.​​
2674
Final
02/10/2020​ Mark Muscat 
vs
HSBC Bank Malta plc ​​
​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​ A.M.​
2675
Final​
06/10/2020​ ​Marga Benitez-Alahija 
vs
Winunited Limited 

Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​ and Unfair Dismissal ​​​ G.V.​
​​2676
Final​
08/10/2020​ Tonio Muscat  
vs
Malta Public Transport Services(Operations) Ltd​​
Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
Final
Decree
3805
08/10/2020​ Jonathan Ellul 
vs
Ascent Software Limited​
Alleged harassment and Alleged unfair dismissal (constructive dismissal)​​ C.C.G.​
​​2677
Final​​​
​12/10/2020 Milovan Camilleri
vs
​NIC Company Limited​
Unfair Dismissal​​ ​J.H.P
Final
Decree
3794​​​
15/10/2020​ ​Katia Borg 
vs
HSBC Bank Malta plc ​

Alleged Discriminatory Treatmen​ M.F.​​
​​2678
Final​
19/10/2020​ ​        Dragan Petrovic
vs
Al Solito Posto Limited​

Unfair Dismissal​​​ J.H.P​
​​​2679
Final​
19/10/2020​ ​​​Laurence Abela 
vs
Cassar Petroleum Services Ltd​​

Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ J.H.P​​
​​​​2680
Final​
​21/10/2020 ​​Abela Medici et.
vs.
Bank of Valletta plc​
Alleged Discrimination​ ​C.C.G
​​Final
Decree
3883​​​
​23/10/2020 ​​Emmanuel Chircop
vs
MMH Malta Ltd ​
Unfair Dismissal​​​ J.B.​
Final
Decree
3871
23/10/2020​ Fabrizio Caggegi
 vs
AKFX Financial Services Limited​
 ​​
Unfair Dismisal ​​​ ​J.B.
2680
Preliminary​​
​28/10/2020 ​Mildred Marmara
& Yvonne Penza
vs
The Nuance Group (Malta) Ltd 
Alleged Discrimination 
​C.C.G


​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​