2021 Decisions

2021 Decisions


* Chairpersons :

JB- Is-sur John Bencini
CC- Is-sur  Charles Cassar  
CCG- Avv. Charmaine Cristiano Grech
MD - Avv.  Marouska Debono
JD- Is-sur Joseph Delia
MF - Avv. Martin Fenech 
JG - Is-sur  Joe Gerada 
FM - Is-sur  Franco Masini 
AM - Avv. Anna Mallia
DP - Is-sinjura Doreen Parnis
JHP - Is-sur James H. Pearsall
ET - Is-sur Edmund Tabone 
GV - Avv. Geoffrey Vella
HW - Is-sur Harold Walls 
​​ ​​​ ​​​​​
Decision
Number &
 Type​​​​​​​
​Date ​Parties ​Subject ​Chairperson*
2693
​​Preliminary
​​07/01/2021 Air Malta plc vs Association of Airline Operations Controllers (Malta) (AAOC) &  General Workers’ Union (GWU)​
​Union Recognition ​E.T.
2694
​​Preliminary
07/01/2​021​

General Workers’ Union (GWU)  & Air Malta plc vs Association of Airline Operations Controllers (Malta) (AAOC)​​
​​​Union Recognition ​E.T.​
Final
Decree
3866

11/01/2021​ N/a vs ​BNF Bank p.l.c.  Alleged Discriminatory Treatment and Unfair Dismissal​​ M.F.​

​2695
Final​
12/01/2021​ Alfred Mallia vs ​Malta Public Transport Services Ltd Unfair Dismissal​​​ D.P.​
​​Final
Decree
3857
​12/01/2021 ​Patricia Camilleri Vs Arringo Limited​​ Unfair Dismissal​​​ H.W.​
​​Final
Decree
3881
12/01/2021​ Audrey Cauchi Vs Arringo Limited ​​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​ ​J.B.
2696
Final​​
​13/01/2021 Antoinette Farrugia​ vs ​Optical (CCSG) Co. Ltd​ &
Classic Group Ltd​

​Unfair Dismissal​​​ C.C.​
2697
Final
14/01/2021​ Sammy M. Hazzouri vs ​Mr Owen Falzon & Ms Arlette Falzon Seychell obo San Filippu Pharma Ltd​ ​​Unfair Dismissal​​​ J.D.​
2698
Final​​
15/01/2021​ Michael Keown ​vs ​Entertainment International Malta Ltd Services Operations Limited ​​ ​​Unfair Dismissal​​​​ J.G.​
2699
Final​​
​15/01/2021 Stephanie Justice  vs ​Ceevo Financial Services (Malta) Ltd Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ ​J.G.​
​​Final
Decree
3890​
18/01/2021​ Yasmine Bolteel vs Lynette Zerafa & Southeast Cafe`​​ ​Unfair Dismissal​ J.H.P​
​​2700
Final
20/01/2021​ Magdalena Strnadova Smotlachova vs Air X Charter Limited  ​​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​ ​F.M.
​​Final
Decree
3
761
​25/01/2021 Lenka Pittoni vs Bethard Group Ltd​​​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment, harassment and  Unfair Dismissal​​​ M.D.​
2701
Final
26/01/2021​ Luciano Callus vs Trelleborg Sealing Solutions Malta Ltd Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​ H.W.​
2702
Final​
26/01/2021​ Kevin Deguara vs Trelleborg Sealing Solutions Malta Ltd​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​ ​H.W.
2703
Final
28/01/2021​ Joseph Bonanno vs All Services Limited​ ​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​ H.W.​
​​Final
Decree
3876
29/01/2021​ Petra Travers-Tauss vs Rubicon Limited ​ Unfair Dismissal J.B.​
​​​Final
Decree
3877
​29/01/2021 Mateja Ristijovic vs Asergis Operations ​​ Unfair Dismissal​ J.B​.
​​​Final
Decree
2704​
​29/01/2021 Connie Ciantar vs Mario Attard  obo Pick ‘n Save’​ Unfair Dismissal​​ J.G.​
​​​Final
Decree
3731
​02/02/2021 Leibig Peggy vs Yield Media Limited​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​ ​​J.G.
2705
Final
02/02/2021​ Deborah Anne sive Debbie Madiona vs Education Limited ​
Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ ​G.V.
2706
Final
​02/02/2021 John Bundy vs Public Broadcasting Services Ltd ​ ​​Unfair Dismissal​​​​ D.P.​
2707
Final​
​08/02/2021 Carolina Fabra Rando vs Jet Magic Air Personnel Limited​ ​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment, and  Unfair Dismissal​​​ M.F.​
2708
Final
  08/02/2021 ​​ Conception Martinez Lopez vs Jet Magic Air Personnel Limited​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment, and  Unfair Dismissal​ M.F.​
Final
Decree
3887
09/02/2021​ Hazem Abo Zidan vs Farstone Construction and Restoration LTD​  Unfair Dismissal​​​ F.M.​
2709
Final
15/02/2021​ Baran Duman vs Tipbet ​​
Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ J.H.P​.
2711
Final
​17/02/2021 ​       Romualdo Farrugia ​ vs Fondazzjoni tal-Kon-Katidral  ta’ San Gwann ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ C.C​.
2710
Final
17/02/2021​        Norman Ellul  vs  Actavis Limited​ ​​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​ C.C.​
2712
​​Preliminary
19/02/2021​ Paul Cachia vs Water Services Corporation & General Workers Union​ ​​​ Alleged abusive conduct and Alleged discriminatory ​treatmen​t​​​ A.M​.
2713
Final
​22/02/2021 Roberta Zammit vs Fondazzjoni għal Servizzi ​Edukattivi​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​ ​J.H.P.
​​3359
Final
24/02/2021​ Tatyana Boyanova Ivanova​ vs WM Environmental Ltd​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​ ​C.C.G.
​​2716
Final​​
25/02/2021​ Thilo Kuhlmann  vs Leo Vegas Gaming plc ​​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​ F.M​.
​​2715
Final
25/02/2021​ Edward Domnic Polidano vs GO Plc​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​​​ E.T​.
2717
​​Preliminary
26/02/2021​ Ivan Milosevic vs Defiant Ltd ​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​​​ J.B​.
​​2718
Final
​01/03/2021 Antoinette Calleja​ vs Direttur Generali fid-Dipartiment tal-Kuntratti​ Discriminatory Treatment​​ M.F​.
2719
Final
03/03/2021​ Anthony k.a. Tony Busuttil vs Cassar Fuel Services Station Limited ​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ C.C.G.​
​​2720
Final​​
​03/03/2021 Sarto Ltd vs Christine Vella​ ​ ​Breach of Agreement​ C.C.G.​
​​​​Final
Decree
3860
10/03/2021​ Arthur Zammit  vs Enemed Co. Ltd. & Engineering Resources Ltd ​Discriminatory Treatment​​ C.C.G​.
​​​​Final
Decree
3746
​12/03/2021 Tabib David Grech vs Medicare Services Ltd​​
Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ C.C.G​
​​2721
Final
12/03/2021​ Anthony Bailey vs Maltacom plc & GOplc  ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ ​A.M.
​​2722
Final
​12/03/2021​ Anna Grixti​ vs  Dar il-Kaptan​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ ​A.M.​
​​​​​Final
Decree
3922
​15/03/2021 Mariusz Florin Ban vs Malta International Airport plc​ Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
​​​​​​Final
Decree
3846
​15/03/2021 Emanuel Abela vs Malta Freeport Terminals ​Limited ​ Unfair Dismissal​ ​H.W.
​​​​​​​Final
Decree
3878
​17/03/2021 Mario Gerada vs JRS Malta Foundation​ Alleged victimisation,harassment​and  Unfair Dismissal​ ​G.V.
2723
Final
24/03/2021​ Alessandro Falco Renzulli vs Esports Tech Limited ​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​ F.M.​
​​​​​​Final
Decree
3850
​25/03/2021 Joshua Buttigieg vs Arringo Limited​ ​​ ​​Unfair Dismissal​​​ D.P.​
2724
Preliminary​
   13/04/2021
Ian Caldicott vs Methode Electronics Malta Ltd​
​Discriminatory Treatment​​ & Unfair ​Dismissal​​​​ ​G.V.
Final
Decree
3632
27/04/2021​ ​Jonathan Micallef  vs Air Malta p.l.c. & l-Union of Cabin Crew Members​ Discriminatory Treatment​​ & Equal Pay for Equal Work’ ​ ​G.V.​​
2725
Final
27/04/2021​ Luke Engerer ​vs International Fashion Company Li​mited,Bay Street Holdings Limited,Bay Street Operations Limited,Bay Street Hotel Complex​ Unfair Dismissal  M.D​​.
Final
Decree
3632
28/04/2021​ Matthew Saviour Felice Pace vs Betsson Services Limited​​ ​​​Unfair Dismissal​​​​ ​J.H.P​​
Final
Decree
2726
04/05/2021​ Justin Camilleri vs Ministeru Ghall-Affarijiet Ewropej u Twettiq tal-Manifest Elettorali​​ Discriminatory Treatment​​ & Unfair ​Dismissal​ G.V.​
Final
Decree
272​7
05/05/2021​ Josef Aquilina vs Heritage Malta Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​ ​C.C.G.
Final
Decree
2728​
05/05/2021​​ Mario Griscti vs Executive Security Services Ltd​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​ C.C.G.​
2729
Final
06/05/2021​ Saviour Caruana vs Malta International Airport plc ​ ​​​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ H.W.​
2730
Preliminary​
06/05/2021​ Malta Union of Bank Employees​ vs Bank of Valletta​ Alleged lack of effect under the Law on the provisions of the Collective Agreement regarding the treatment of an employee Mr Mario Farrugia​ ​J.D.
2731
Final​​
06/05/2021​ ​Kevin Agius vs Malta Freeport Terminals Limited​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ ​J.D.​
2732
Final
07/05/2021​ Doreen Saliba vs Foster Clark Products Ltd ​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ J.G.​
2733
Final
07/05/2021​ Dirk Farrugia vs Federated Mills plc ​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​ J.G​.
​​2734
Final
07/05/2021​ Ivan Johnston vs Air Malta plc ​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​ J.G.​
​​2735
Final
07/05/2021​ Marieta Koseva vs Zoya Kirilova​ ​ Unfair Dismissal​ J.G​​.
Final
Decree
3823
11/05/2021​ Anthony Pace Vs Greens SuperMarket Limited  ​​​Unfair Dismissa​l​ J.H.P.​​​​​​
Final
Decree
3901
11/05/2021​ Jason Caruana vs Public Broadcasting Services Ltd ​​​ Unfair Dismissa​l​​ ​C.C.
Final
Decree
3895
​13/05/2021 Rosanne Finan vs Baum Malta Ltd​  Unfair Dismissa​l​​​ J.D​
2736
Final
14/05/2021​ Michael Sciberras vs Malta Freeport Corporation​​ Unfair Dismissa​l​​​ ​A.M.
Final
Decree
3856
12/05/2021​ Michael Micallef vs Arringo Limited​​​ ​​​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ H.W.​
2737
Final
​18/05/2021 Baldacchino Neville Paul  vs Munchies Yue Bristro Ltd ​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ ​H.W.
Final
Decree
3890
​19/05/2021 Muscat Adriana vs Malta Air Limited​ ​ ​Dwar allegazzjoni ta ’vjolenza morali, theddid u fastidju u dwar allegazzjoni ta’ tkeccija ngusta (constructive dismissal) A.M.​
Final
Decree
3958
19/05/2021​ Joseph Persiano vs Malta Freeport Terminals Ltd.​ ​
Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​ C.C.G.​
​​2738
Final
20/05/2021​ Antoine Cassar vs Malta Freeport Terminals Ltd.​  ​​​​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ H.W.​
Final
Decree
3832
24/05/2021​ Ivan Mula vs Michael Debono Limited u Wotomoto Limited​​ ​​​​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​ C.C​
Final
Decree
3698
03/06/2021​ Marlene Busuttil vs Healthmark Care Services Ltd​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​ ​E.T.
​​2739
Final
08/06/2021​ George Agius vs Arkadia Marketing Limited ​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​ ​G.V.
2740
Preliminary​​
​09/06/2021 Thilo Kuhlmann vs Leo Vegas Gaming plc​ ​       Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​ ​F.M.
Final
Decree
3886
16/06/2021​ Philip Gatt vs Kunsill Lokali Haz-Zebbug​​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​ ​J.B.
2741
Final
18/06/2021 Giannella Mifsud vs Skola Sekondarja tal-Konservatorju tal-isqof and Christine Scerri​ ​​ Alleged Discriminatory​ and ​​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​
A.M.​
Final
Decree
3900
​21/06/2021 Alain Michel Hanny vs Air X Charter Limited ​​ ​Unfair Dismissal​ D.P.​
2742
Final
25/06/2021​ Nebojsa Vujakovic  vs  Bilom Construction Limited ​​ Unfair Dismissal​​​ ​J.G
Final
Decree
3730
30/06/2021​ Mario Fava vs Malta Public Transport Services (Operations) Limited​ ​ Unfair Dismissal​ ​M.D.
Final
Decree
3914
07/07/2021​ Silvana Mifsud Bonnici vs Transport Malta​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​​​​ C.C.G.​
Final
Decree
3410
09/07/2021​ ​Daniel Magrin vs Bank of Valletta plc ​​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​ G.V.​
2744
Final
​09/07/2021 Maria Carmela Fatima vs Lina Tonna​​ Unfair Dismissal​​​ J.B.​
2743
Preliminary​​​​​​​
09/07/2021 Colin Galea & Brady Francis Scerri Sevasta vs Air X Jet Support (Malta) Ltd​
​Unfair Dismissal​​​ ​J.B.
Final
Decree
3632
13/07/2021​ Jonathan Micallef  vs Air Malta p.l.c. & l-Union of Cabin Crew Members​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​ ​ G.V.​
2745
Final
​13/07/2021 ​​Katia Fenech vs Kunsill Lokali Dingli​​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​ ​​ G.V.​
2746
Final
14/07/2021​ Federica Santucci vs Casa Holding Limited​ ​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ F.M.​
2747
Final
15/07/2021​ Emanuel Caruana  vs Detention Service Officer Ministry for Home Affairs​​ ​​Unfair Dismissal​ M.D.​
Final
Decree
3893
15/07/2021​ David John Pace vs Citadel Insurance PLC​​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​ J.B.​
Final
Decree
3939
19/07/2021​ Jacopo Tortora vs Unpaused Company Limited ​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​ J.H.P​​
2748
Final
19/07/2021​ Gilbert Scerri vs Malta Freeport Terminals Ltd​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ J.H.P​
Final
Decree
2749
​2​2/07/2021 Marcus Klaushofer vs Malta International Airport plc​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​ ​E.T.
2750
Final​
​30/0​7/2021 Mario Farrugia vs Signal 8 Security Services Malta Limited​ ​​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​ J.G.​
Final
Decree
3875
12/08/2021​ Rossmark Caruana vs Bonju Limited ​​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​ ​J.B.​​
Final
Decree
3957
30/08/2021​ Noorul-Ain Khan vs APS Bank plc​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​ M.D.​
2751
Final​​
03/09/2021​ Paul Vella vs KVH Computers​ ​ ​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​
J.G.​
2752
Final​​
13/09/2021​ Ludmilla Moraru vs Mark Camilleri ​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​ ​J.H.P
Final
Decree
3680
13/09/2021​ Leon Caruana vs Bank of Valletta plc ​ ​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​  M.F.​
2753
Preliminary​​​
14/09/2021​ Araceli Porras Leon vs Air X Charter Ltd ​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​​ D.P.​
2754
Final​​
14/09/2021​ Samuel Curmi vs Executive Security Services Ltd Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​​ D.P.​
2755
Final​​
15/09/2021​ Christopher Briffa vs The Nuance Group Malta Limited​​ Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​​​​​ ​C.C.
2756
Final​​
16/09/2021​ Johann Briffa vs Bay Street Hotel Complex Ltd​ Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ H.W.​
2757
Final​​
​16/09/2021 Lorelle Degabriele vs Elmo Pensions Limited​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal H.W.​
2758
Final​​
16/09/2021​ Anthony Apap vs Attard & Co.​​ ​​Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
2759
Final​​
​16/09/2021 Ashleigh Pandurov vs ​S&M (Marketing) Company  Ltd.​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal E.T.​
2760
Final​​
23/09/2021​ Mario Farrugia vs Awtorita Maltija dwar il-Loghob​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal H.W.​
2761
Final​​
​27/09/2021 Sylvia Bartolo u Mireille Gheiti vs Actavis Limited​ ​Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​​ M.F.​
2762
Final​​
28/09/2021​ ​Luke Vella vs Piscopo Gardens Ltd.​ ​​Alleged Unfair Dismissal H.W.​
2763
Final​​
​29/09/2021 Steven Paton vs Sarto Limited VF Group Limited​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal C.C.G.​
2764
Final​​
30/09/2021​ Emanuel Cordina vs Zenith Malta Division Ltd.​ Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ H.W.​
2765
Final
07/10/2021 Tania Di Giancamillo vs Arti Brands Limited​​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal ​J.D.
2766
Final
07/10/2021​ Josef Zammit vs Malta Freeport Terminals Limited​ Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ J.D.​
2767
Final
08/10/2021​ ​Philippe Jean Guillaut vs HOSI Malta Limited​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ ​J.G.
Final
Decree
3367
​08/10/2021 Mary Downing vs SMS Group Limited​ Alleged Sexual Harassment​ A.M.​
2768
Final
​13/10/2021 Iana Podoliscaia vs Prestige Travel Marketing Limited​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​​​ C.C.G.​
2769
Final
14/10/2021​ Andrew Giordimaina vs Mediterranean Offshore Bunkering Company Limited ​​Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ E.T.​
Final
Decree
3972
​14/10/2021 ​AnneMarie McAlister vs Invicti Security Limited​ ​​Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ ​E.T.
Final
Decree
3943
25/10/2021​ Angel Ricardo Rivas Ortis vs High End Properties Limited​ ​​​Alleged Unfair Dismissal​​ H.W.​
2770
Preliminar​y
26/10/2021​ Peter Kriznar vs Eden Hospitality Ltd. Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ ​H.W.
Final
2771
​26/10/2021 Elton John Debono vs Oiltanking Malta Limited​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ H.W.​
Final
2772
​27/10/2021 Joseph Schem​bri vs Steward Malta Personnel Limited​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal​​ C.C.​
Final
2773
​29/10/2021​ S.R.G.N. Company Limited​ vs Marlon Garcia​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal​​​ J.G.​
Final
2774
​1/11/2021 Muhammed Amadou vs Ditta Mifsud & Grima​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal ​J.H.P.
Final
2775
3/11/2021​ ​Mariella Mallia vs Elmein Limited​ Alleged Unfair Dismissal​​​ ​F.M.
2776
Preliminary
​9/11/2021 Doreen Camilleri vs L-Agenzija tal-Programmi ta’ l-Unjoni Ewropea (“EUPA”)​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​​​​ ​G.V.
Final
2777
9/11/2021​ ​Johann Ellul vs J.F. Services Limited u Wasteserv Malta Ltd​ Alleged Unfair Dismissal​​​​ ​D.P.
Final
Decree
3044
​9/11/2021 Larry Duca vs Office Group Limited​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal ​M.F.
Final
Decree
3596
​9/11/2021 Victor G. Scerri vs Wasteserv Malta Ltd Alleged Discriminatory​ and ​​Unfair Dismissal​​​​​​​​ M.F.​
Final
Decree
3666
9/11/2021​ Malta Union of Bank Employees vs Bank of Valletta (BOV)​ Alleged Discriminatory Treatment​​​​​​​​ C.C.G.​
2778
Preliminary​​
12/11/2021​ Daniele Ramella Pollone vs 3DZ Franchising Limited​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ J.G.​
2779
Preliminary
​12/11/2021 Luca d’Urbano vs 3DZ Franchising Limited​ Alleged Unfair Dismissal​​ ​J.G.
Final
Decree
3911
15/11/2021​ ​Liubov Untevskaya vs Saint James (Capua) Hospital Ltd.​ Alleged Victimization and Harassment​ A.M.​
Final
Decree
3993
​15/11/2021 Christienne Felice vs The Computer Training Course Ltd​ Alleged Unfair Dismissal​​​ J.D.​
Final
Decree
3845
19/11/2021​ Salvatore Lopes vs NGP EMS Limited​ Alleged Unfair Dismissal​​ F.M.​
Final
2780
​24/11/2021 Lorraine Farrugia vs Lead Service Technologies Ltd​ Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ F.M.​
Final
2783
​1/12/2021 Joseph Spiteri vs Tlata Limited​ ​Alleged Unfair Dismissal​ C.C.​
​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​